Brady vs Manning Debate to end this year? - New England Patriots Forums

mesoslo · 12-27-2007, 04:42 AM

If tom brady leads the patriots to an undefeated regular season(break manning single season touchdown record and help Randy Moss break the most touchdown record for a WR) and also win the superbowl. Will those things be used to cement Brady as the best QB ever and better than peyton manning.

PatsFanInVa · 12-27-2007, 04:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mesoslo

If tom brady leads the patriots to an undefeated regular season(break manning single season touchdown record and help Randy Moss break the most touchdown record for a WR) and also win the superbowl. Will those things be used to cement Brady as the best QB ever and better than peyton manning.

Only in New England.

Plus, as FoxSports reminds us, he's no Bert Jones.

PFnV

nhpatsfan · 12-27-2007, 04:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mesoslo

If tom brady leads the patriots to an undefeated regular season(break manning single season touchdown record and help Randy Moss break the most touchdown record for a WR) and also win the superbowl. Will those things be used to cement Brady as the best QB ever and better than peyton manning.

Unfortunately, no. Peyton the flasher will remain a media darling.

speed · 12-27-2007, 06:54 AM

Maybe when Brady catches him on some of the career stats, that will help put an end to the arguement, but it's still subjective.

Manning is top 10 or so in almost every career NFL stat and has 6 at least top level years, maybe 8, if he stays away from injuries.

Brady keeps playing like he is, though he'll be right there, too.

There's certainly a great argument in Brady's favor though, if he does it this year.

***Menlo*** · 12-27-2007, 07:09 AM

Peyton all day everday! Brady, to me, is just a pretty boy who plays under Bill.

fair catch fryar · 12-27-2007, 07:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nugget Type Of Fellow

Peyton all day everday! Brady, to me, is just a pretty boy who plays under Bill.

Looks like we need some more "Troll Away" spray! Damn bugs!

***Menlo*** · 12-27-2007, 07:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fair catch fryar

Looks like we need some more "Troll Away" spray! Damn bugs!

Troll? Not really, I have better things to do than fool around for amusement. Peyton>Brady and you and I know it. Brady is only good because he plays under Bill, want to disagree?

Drewwho · 12-27-2007, 07:21 AM

The debate is over and has been for a while. Manning, even in the playoffs last year, was weak. He still does not bring it consistently to the 'big' games.

Brady has proven to do more with less and more with more!

Manning has fallen out as media darling. Sure he is great in his own right, but now it is universally known that Brady is 1A and Manning is 1B.

Manning = great passer, not great in the clutch, throws teammates under the bus, 1 championship, most TD etc...
Brady = great QB, great in the clutch, great leader, 3 Championships, 21 game winning streak and ...counting...

***richpats*** · 12-27-2007, 07:31 AM

January 20th. We'll know then.

BHSL2 · 12-27-2007, 07:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nugget Type Of Fellow

Peyton all day everday! Brady, to me, is just a pretty boy who plays under Bill.

Since this is the only argument you have and it is ****ty, I declare you stupid. Tell me, how exactly does Matt Cassel do when he comes in? This "Brady is a system player" crap is old. He's thrown 48 friggin TD passes. That is NOT a system player. Go talk to Trent DIlfer.