Some Special Teams analysis - Ravens game - Page 2 - New England Patriots Forums

***ctpatsfan77*** · 10-10-2009, 09:27 AM

Well, FWIW, I think whatever issues he has with speed are probably related to mental issues; his 40 time at his pro day was certainly not worse than Welker's (his worst 40 = WW's best 40).

And let's not forget that Edelman's also hasn't been at 100% himself the last few games (remember that whole "Questionable (ankle)" thing?).

Patspsycho · 10-10-2009, 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mgteich

I don't think Edelman will be returning many kicks or punts after the bye. We will better options (not terribly difficult). Even Slater has looked better in the past. With Welker, Tate, Maroney and Faulk healthy, I don't see Edelman returning kicks or punts.

Edelman beat out Lewis for a roster spot. He can do many things. And perhaps by next season, he will perform some of these roles well, or not. Don't get me wrong. Edelman is doing fine for a rookie backup.

For now, Edelman is a weak link in the special teams. It will be good to see Slater back to close to 100%. BTW, it is not clear whi Lockett is on the team if he can't play teams better than Edelman.

Welker was injured. Edelman filled in.
Welker and Tate have been injured. Edelman has been tried as a returner.
Slater has been injured. Edelman has been tried as a special team blocker.

I believe Lockett is basically a roster filler that becomes expendable when the team needs a player, which is probably pretty soon- e.g., Junior Seau.

***patchick*** · 10-10-2009, 10:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by satz

Its not edel is blocking is bad he is taking on a faster guy and is just getting out positioned.

I think exceping edel to be another wes is too much too.edel is slower and will not be that speed guy ever.as we all know we cannot teach speed.

I think we can all agree that Edelman hasn't looked good so far blocking on special teams, but I don't think raw speed/athleticism is the reason. (Edelman would win a simple footrace over Welker any day.)

As far as I can tell, Edelman has never been asked to block in his life. He was a QB straight through high school and college, and his role on special teams was as an occasional punt returner -- and punter, for good measure.