LOL,
@fnordcircle - your story is eerily similar to mine, though I did not live in the boonies nor did I possess an 80 mph fastball.
Little League baseball. The best players got to play the whole game, the rest got substituted and only played 2-3 innings. I don't remember the details but our team needed a catcher. I jumped at the opportunity because that meant I would play the whole game.
Soon I became very good at the position, probably the best in the league. With more at bats I had became our team's best/2nd best hitter too. By then what I really wanted to do was pitch. I would throw the ball back to our pitcher as hard as I could in an attempt to impress my coach. My pitchers would complain; at times after catching my throw they would wince in pain, even going so far as to take off their glove and shake their hand it was so sore.
Eventually got my chance. First two batters both struck out on three pitches. Next guy kept fouling off pitches and eventually walked. Struck out the next batter to end the inning.
Coach had a big smile as we returned to the dugout. Whole team was jubilant. Life was grand.
Until the next inning.
Similarly, for whatever reason I could not get the ball over the plate. Our opponent - comprised entirely of friends and neighbors who went to the same elementary school as me - batted around. I took a little heat off the fastball, just trying to avoid more walks. Next thing I know there's a monstrous high fly ball over the left field fence, grand slam. Some dork in right field was yelling to take me out, and our opponent's dugout was going crazy. It was a Southwest Airlines "Want To Get Away" real life moment. I managed to finish the inning without further damage and the coach mercifully brought in somebody else to pitch the next inning.
Next game it was back to catcher - and I never got another chance to pitch again.