OT: NEUTRAL arbitrator overturns Goondell Suspension of Texans LT

Pro Bowl Player's Suspension Overturned With The Help Of Neutral Arbitration

Commisioner Idiot suspends a player 10 games over beef he ate that contained PEDs.

You would hope if there are any Texans fans who think Brady should just accept his punishment, that maybe they would rethink their position.

I heard that he destroyed those burgers.

JJ Watt would have turned over his beef...

Why does everyone except Brady get a neutral arbitrator ? Oh wait, don't answer that...we all know why !

Gee, a neutral third-party observing the facts of the case determines that the NFL was out of line in its punishment. Color me shocked.

This is helpful.........I think?

Not sure to what extent.

Foxypats said:

Why does everyone except Brady get a neutral arbitrator ? Oh wait, don't answer that...we all know why !

Click to expand...

He did. Vincent handed down the punishment and Goodell has no dog in this fight in his quest for integrity. Er wait no Vincent can't hand down the punishment he uh..well yeah don't worry about it integrity.

Vincent is far from Neutral. He is a pompous a hole , Brady should have been heard by Tagliabue. Oh wait, I guess Goober doesn't like Tags anymore after his ruling about Bounty gate !

The Gr8est said:

You would hope if there are any Texans fans who think Brady should just accept his punishment, that maybe they would rethink their position.

Click to expand...

I wouldn't hold my breath on that one.

IIRC, PED disputes are negotiated through a neutral arbitrator. Part of the CBA.

Koma said:

I wouldn't hold my breath on that one.

Click to expand...

Kraft should say he's disappointed that McNair wouldn't urge Brown to just accept the punishment and move on.

Dorito Dink said:

Gee, a neutral third-party observing the facts of the case determines that the NFL was out of line in its punishment. Color me shocked.

Click to expand...

I thought facts wouldn't matter. Judge Chin says that the NFL have the right to make any rulingthey want with no need to base it on facts or fairness? Why not have Ted Wells or the firm he represents be the primary arbitrator? Or would that be Arbitraitor?

oldrover said:

IIRC, PED disputes are negotiated through a neutral arbitrator. Part of the CBA.

Click to expand...

but didn't Goodell verbally equate deflategate to PEDs?

IllegalContact said:

but didn't Goodell verbally equate deflategate to PEDs?

Click to expand...

Didn't Brady also get suspended by a policy that only applies to teams?

oldrover said:

IIRC, PED disputes are negotiated through a neutral arbitrator. Part of the CBA.

Click to expand...

Ah, but Goodell compared deflating footballs to using PEDs, so the situation really should have gone to a neutral arbitrator.

(Illegal Contact beat me to it.)

Wait a minute...

Goodell previously claimed that that "the closest parallel" for what Brady did is "steroid use;" therefore the discipline should be handled according to the previously established PED policy; in reference to the CBA: "In terms of the appropriate level of discipline, the closest parallel of which I am aware is the collectively bargained discipline imposed for a first violation of the policy governing performance enhancing drugs..."

So, by Goodell's own warped-logic; isn't he essentially making the statement that there should be a neutral arbitrator for Deflategate?

oldrover said:

IIRC, PED disputes are negotiated through a neutral arbitrator. Part of the CBA.

Click to expand...

Well since ****-brick decided that deflating footballs is equivalent to steroid-use it should have gone to a neutral arbitrator as well.

These nitwits have as much logic as a 2 year old. Come to think of it, when my kids were 2 they had more logic than the NFL.

Froob said:

He did. Vincent handed down the punishment and Goodell has no dog in this fight in his quest for integrity. Er wait no Vincent can't hand down the punishment he uh..well yeah don't worry about it integrity.

Click to expand...

Vincent is part of goodell's goon squad who's responsibilty was to issue punishments. He was not the arbitrator whose job is to handle appeals.