PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Patriots Legal Counsel Rebuttal of Wells Report


Status
Not open for further replies.
Expecting that the Patriots won't mind a little copy-and-paste on their side of things, and since I commented on this very issue in the thread regarding whether or not JM and JJ could/should sue the NFL, I was startled to read this bit of information:

The report acknowledges that game officials specifically allowed Mr. McNally to take the game footballs from the dressing room of the Officials’ Locker Room (where the referee was) into the separate sitting room (pg. 55). No one told Mr. McNally that he could not then proceed to the field with the footballs. When the NFC Championship Game ended abruptly in overtime and Mr. McNally started from the back of the sitting room towards the door to the hallway, he walked by numerous League officials in the sitting room. As the report states (pg. 55), the sitting room was crowded with “NFL personnel, game officials and others gathered there to watch the conclusion of the NFC Championship Game on television.” Mr. McNally had to navigate this crowd of officials to make it through the sitting room with two large bags of footballs on his shoulders. Mr. McNally, a physically big man, hoisted two large bags of footballs and lumbered past all these League officials and out the door of the Officials’ Locker Room. As is clear from the report, no one objected; no one told him to stop; no one requested that he wait to be accompanied by a League official; no one told him that a League official had to carry the footballs to the field. After he walked past all of these League officials and out the door of the Officials’ Locker Room to the hallway, he then walked past James Daniel, an NFL official and one of the people who had been alerted to the Colts psi concerns pre-game (pg. 45). Mr. Daniel, as seen on the security video, looked at Mr. McNally carrying the bags of footballs toward the field unaccompanied by any League or game official, and made no objection to Mr. McNally continuing unaccompanied to the field. In short, if officials lost track of the location of game footballs, it was not because Mr. McNally stealthily removed them. (Omitted from the investigation were interviews with all those League officials whom Mr. McNally walked past with the bags of footballs on his shoulders.) Even after halftime, when obvious attention was being paid to game footballs and psi issues by League and game officials, who took control of the footballs at halftime, the security video shows Mr. McNally, with no objection, taking the footballs from the Officials’ Locker Room back to the field totally unaccompanied by any League or Game official. Mr. McNally’s removal of the footballs from the Officials’ Locker Room before the game began was simply not unauthorized, unknown, unusual, or in violation of some protocol or instruction. The report nonetheless portrays Mr. McNally’s departure from the Officials’ Locker Room before the game as a step in secretly taking the footballs for nefarious reasons.

If you read the Wells Report from around page 48 to page 60, everything McNally did is expressed as completely unusual, almost without precedence, and the people who say it happened half the time (the tunnel security guards) are dismissed by Wells.

So let me put this bit out there one more time from the above quote:

Even after halftime, when obvious attention was being paid to game footballs and psi issues by League and game officials, who took control of the footballs at halftime, the security video shows Mr. McNally, with no objection, taking the footballs from the Officials’ Locker Room back to the field totally unaccompanied by any League or Game official.

Holy crap.
I know one thing for certain. Brady isn't serving a game. This report is ********. This is proof of it.
 
Expecting that the Patriots won't mind a little copy-and-paste on their side of things, and since I commented on this very issue in the thread regarding whether or not JM and JJ could/should sue the NFL, I was startled to read this bit of information:

The report acknowledges that game officials specifically allowed Mr. McNally to take the game footballs from the dressing room of the Officials’ Locker Room (where the referee was) into the separate sitting room (pg. 55). No one told Mr. McNally that he could not then proceed to the field with the footballs. When the NFC Championship Game ended abruptly in overtime and Mr. McNally started from the back of the sitting room towards the door to the hallway, he walked by numerous League officials in the sitting room. As the report states (pg. 55), the sitting room was crowded with “NFL personnel, game officials and others gathered there to watch the conclusion of the NFC Championship Game on television.” Mr. McNally had to navigate this crowd of officials to make it through the sitting room with two large bags of footballs on his shoulders. Mr. McNally, a physically big man, hoisted two large bags of footballs and lumbered past all these League officials and out the door of the Officials’ Locker Room. As is clear from the report, no one objected; no one told him to stop; no one requested that he wait to be accompanied by a League official; no one told him that a League official had to carry the footballs to the field. After he walked past all of these League officials and out the door of the Officials’ Locker Room to the hallway, he then walked past James Daniel, an NFL official and one of the people who had been alerted to the Colts psi concerns pre-game (pg. 45). Mr. Daniel, as seen on the security video, looked at Mr. McNally carrying the bags of footballs toward the field unaccompanied by any League or game official, and made no objection to Mr. McNally continuing unaccompanied to the field. In short, if officials lost track of the location of game footballs, it was not because Mr. McNally stealthily removed them. (Omitted from the investigation were interviews with all those League officials whom Mr. McNally walked past with the bags of footballs on his shoulders.) Even after halftime, when obvious attention was being paid to game footballs and psi issues by League and game officials, who took control of the footballs at halftime, the security video shows Mr. McNally, with no objection, taking the footballs from the Officials’ Locker Room back to the field totally unaccompanied by any League or Game official. Mr. McNally’s removal of the footballs from the Officials’ Locker Room before the game began was simply not unauthorized, unknown, unusual, or in violation of some protocol or instruction. The report nonetheless portrays Mr. McNally’s departure from the Officials’ Locker Room before the game as a step in secretly taking the footballs for nefarious reasons.

If you read the Wells Report from around page 48 to page 60, everything McNally did is expressed as completely unusual, almost without precedence, and the people who say it happened half the time (the tunnel security guards) are dismissed by Wells.

So let me put this bit out there one more time from the above quote:

Even after halftime, when obvious attention was being paid to game footballs and psi issues by League and game officials, who took control of the footballs at halftime, the security video shows Mr. McNally, with no objection, taking the footballs from the Officials’ Locker Room back to the field totally unaccompanied by any League or Game official.

Holy crap.


Maybe the Sharks Of Vegas were right. The investigation was going to the referees. Of course, the NFL doesn't want to look bad so they stopped that investigation and made sure Wells ignored the referees and just go after the Pats.
 
It does not matter what the LCD mediots think over something a frivolous as the essence of turns of phrases within a string of text messages.

Let them lap up this chaff whilst the wheat of the issue continues to go over all of their heads: there are no direct admissions of guilt therein of tampering with footballs after the officials inspections in the texts.

The important point in all of this is that the Patriots are NOT going away quietly into the night this time...
 
I really hope this goes to court and McNally gets called to the stands "So Mr. McNally, what did you mean when you texted Mr. Jastremki "Dorito Dink?"
 
Media will focus in the deflator word because they are stupid, Patriots nailed it if they show the video of mcnally taking the footballs with the referees present, and taking the footballs again to the field for the 3rd quarter, when wells said he stole the bags and ran to the bathroom LOL
 
I wish they had better explanation for the Deflator and ESPN texts because that is what everyone will focus on.

Of course, if what they're saying is the truth, it's not a question of better/worse. Honestly, taken together with the jacket text, the deflator thing feels truthful to me.
 
strange explanation.

freeman's killing the pats on twitter like usual.

my only question, why suspend mcnally if he did nothing wrong? looks " shady "
 
Their explanation of that does seem a bit ridiculous, but who the hell knows. The texts really don't look that great for the Pats no matter how they're spun.
I does sound like a ridiculous explanation but its also possible its true . I hope the pats have done their research with mcnally and are confident with this explanation.
 
That doesn't explain why they were suspended though. I'm assuming there's a good reason, I'm honestly just curious what it is.

I imagine for a lot of things.

What they said about Tom, the fact that Jast was feeding McNally items to be sold which must have been against the rules because they talk about not doing in front of their boss etc..

That or McNally bragging he had stolen the 50,000 ball from Kraft/Brady.
 
strange explanation.

freeman's killing the pats on twitter like usual.

my only question, why suspend mcnally if he did nothing wrong? looks " shady "


Shady? The league just did the same thing with Hardy and Peterson, calling it the Commissioner's exempt list.
 
I imagine for a lot of things.

What they said about Tom, the fact that Jast was feeding McNally items to be sold which must have been against the rules because they talk about not doing in front of their boss etc..

That or McNally bragging he had stolen the 50,000 ball from Kraft/Brady.
That's reasonable. In context of all of this nonsense it seems unfortunate, but hardly damning.
 
My take is that like the Wells report, some stuff looks like it are significant points that poke big holes in the Wells report and others are questionable.

I wish they had better explanation for the Deflator and ESPN texts because that is what everyone will focus on.
Right now I think they will mock the pats explanation for that unless Mcnally comes out and explains it himself.
 
What pay has McNally missed?
My understanding from this forum (taken with the appropriate grain of sand) was that both individuals were suspended without pay. Obviously does not impact McNally who's only a game day employee. But then, why suspend him as the next game's not for many months to come?
 
That "deflator" excuse about being fat is comical. This can't really be their defense right?
 
My understanding from this forum (taken with the appropriate grain of sand) was that both individuals were suspended without pay. Obviously does not impact McNally who's only a game day employee. But then, why suspend him as the next game's not for many months to come?

Because that's what happens. It happens all the time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


TRANSCRIPT: Patriots QB Drake Maye Conference Call
Patriots Now Have to Get to Work After Taking Maye
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf and Jerod Mayo After Patriots Take Drake Maye
Thursday Patriots Notebook 4/25: News and Notes
Patriots Kraft ‘Involved’ In Decision Making?  Zolak Says That’s Not the Case
MORSE: Final First Round Patriots Mock Draft
Slow Starts: Stark Contrast as Patriots Ponder Which Top QB To Draft
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/24: News and Notes
Tuesday Patriots Notebook 4/23: News and Notes
MORSE: Final 7 Round Patriots Mock Draft, Matthew Slater News
Back
Top