If Big Ben wins 3, where does that put Manning.... - New England Patriots Forums

NENGFAN · 01-18-2011, 08:09 PM

I was thinking that so far it has always been Brady v Manning despite Ben having 2 rings vs 1 of Manning. Now if Ben gets 3 - I still think people will put Brady above Ben BUT where does that put Manning? Surely with 1 ring - I can't think how anyone can put Manning ahead of Ben. Will it now be Ben vs Brady instead of Manning vs Brady? That might be the only positive in case the Steelers do end up winning....

**Ian** · 01-18-2011, 08:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NENGFAN

I was thinking that so far it has always been Brady v Manning despite Ben having 2 rings vs 1 of Manning. Now if Ben gets 3 - I still think people will put Brady above Ben BUT where does that put Manning? Surely with 1 ring - I can't think how anyone can put Manning ahead of Ben. Will it now be Ben vs Brady instead of Manning vs Brady? That might be the only positive in case the Steelers do end up winning....

Nothing positive can come from that - believe me

coolguy · 01-18-2011, 08:15 PM

LOL it still stays the same.

Ben is this generations Terry bradshaw and steeler fans know it.

Troy is the leader of that team.

***parthasas*** · 01-18-2011, 08:17 PM

If big ben wins his third, god help Brady and his legacy

On the other hand, I have a serious jealousy about how PITT is able to maintain a great D year after year.

coolguy · 01-18-2011, 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by parthasas

If big ben wins his third, god help Brady and his legacy

On the other hand, I have a serious jealousy about how PITT is able to maintain a great D year after year.

LOL that sound would the same silly argument steeler fans say when try to say bradshaw was as good as montana

jcdavey · 01-18-2011, 08:53 PM

montana's number #1

brady's #2

but ben winning his 3rd and being 3-0 without losing any sbs, that's gonna put him in some good company, company manning and brady aren't part of, but still brady maintains #2 despite his recent sucking in the playoffs

Fball · 01-18-2011, 08:59 PM

Kind of shows why SB's are not a perfect gauge of QB play. Ben's 1st one was pretty awful; they won despite his play...

upstater1 · 01-18-2011, 09:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jcdavey

montana's number #1

brady's #2

but ben winning his 3rd and being 3-0 without losing any sbs, that's gonna put him in some good company, company manning and brady aren't part of, but still brady maintains #2 despite his recent sucking in the playoffs

This is just lame thinking by you. you have to get to Super Bowl to lose it.

Explain to me why it's better to lose the AFCCG?

Go back and look at Montana's record, and then look at Brady's record in the AFCCG.

Are we going to argue that Brady is better because he has a better championship game record?

jcdavey · 01-18-2011, 10:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by upstater1

This is just lame thinking by you. you have to get to Super Bowl to lose it.

Explain to me why it's better to lose the AFCCG?

Go back and look at Montana's record, and then look at Brady's record in the AFCCG.

Are we going to argue that Brady is better because he has a better championship game record?

sb is the most clutch stage of the game, and montana was perfect there, no losses, nary an int even

end of debate, sorry

brady = #2

patsfan-1982 · 01-18-2011, 11:07 PM

Defense Wins Championships... when Brady had one he got 3 rings when Manning, had one that played good in the playoffs he got one and big ben has all ways had a top defense and if he gets 3 good for him.

as far as who is the GOAT who cares i say just watch and enjoy Brady he will be done in a few years and the pats may end up with a average QB and 10 win seasons could be hard to come by