AndyJohnson

My take:
On offense, the WRs would. Dallas Clark would not. He has bigger catch numbers than our TEs, but wouldn't start in our system over our more well-rounded guys. (At the same time he may start over our guys in the Colts system) Addai wouldnt. Manning wouldn't. I suppose if you had all 10 of the starting OL on the same team, Light (IMO, he is clearly better than Glenn) Mankins, Koppen (clearly better than Saturday) would easily start. Neal, IMO would, and the players would be shifted around a bit so one Colt OL started, probably Glenn at RT.
On D, no one on their DL would start. (I imagine, maybe possibly we would play more 43 to get Freeney in, but he so weak vs the run, I doubt he would play in any situations other than nickel/dime)
At LB, I think Brackett, today would start inside, with Vrabel moving outside, and TBC to the bench. June would have to try and become a safety to play on our D. Freeney couldn't handle the run from an OLB position in the 34 either.
At corner, no one they have would start for us. Sanders would be a starter at safety, and if both Harrison and Wilson were healthy, we'd probably move Wilson to corner because we could afford to. I dont believe Sanders would start over Wilson though if they didnt make that move, because we use our safeties very differently than the colts, and Wilsons strengths fit our D better.

What does everyone else think?

sarge

On offense???

Everyone but Clark Addai and Manning

AndyJohnson

Our OL is better

Remix 6

ahahasgahahahaha

your funny

this woudl be roster if we had Colt players

QB - Brady
RB - Maroney
FB - Evans
WR - Harrison/Wayne
TE - i think Clark is better than Watson..better hands at least...idk
OL - Glenn-Mankins-Saturday-Neal-Diem

3-4 D
DE- Seymour
DE-Warren
DT- Wilfork
OLB-Colvin/Vrabel
ILB-Bruschi/Seau
CB-Samuel/Harper
SS-Harrison
FS-Sanders

AndyJohnson

Which of their OL would you start ahead of our guys?

AndyJohnson

#1 there is NO WAY IN THE WORLD that saturday is better than Koppen. I cant even say its close. I agree with you on Diem, and disagree on Glenn. He and Light are basically a draw as pass blockers and Light is a much better run blocker IMO. But it is a subjective thing. No way I give in on Koppen, but I could accept 3 of our 5 start over theirs.


I disagree on Harper. I think he is in the bottom 20% of starting corners, and Hobbs is just a better player. (Scott is too)


The only other thing we disagree on is TE.
Clark as a receiver only as I said, is at this point, ahead of our TEs, but Watson has much greater potential. But as a complete TE, its not even close. We require TEs to be much better blockers than Clark is.

Remix 6

Harper is a pretty good CB in the league..David is their bad 1

i also think Koppen is abetter center..no idea why i picked Saturday..guess the pro bowls fooled me

AndyJohnson

NO I'm talking about Harper. He is not a good corner. I'd predict he wouldn't have survived camp in NE much less be a starter on this team.

AndyJohnson

Cool, Im glad I didnt have to fight to defend Koppen. I would because he deserves the recognition, and is one of those guys that doesnt get it.

Terry Glenn is a cowgirl

I wouldn't mind having Bob Sanders.