10-26-2009, 03:52 PM
|
#8
|
|
Practice Squad
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Dancing behind the line of scrimmage
Posts: 232
|
Re: PD Game Ball - Brandon Meriweather
Quote:
Originally Posted by The_Riddler
What ? Tell me who is playing better than Brandon right now aside from the 2 obvious ones.
|
That wasn't the original premise of the comment. The original premise was "Meriweather is the third best safety in the NFL".
I agree, Meriweather is outplaying a lot of safeties right now, in fact he's outplaying safeties who are flat out better than him right now.
At risk of sounding like the "guy who just hates Meriweather on Patsfans.com", which I don't, I'll say this: End of game situation where we need a big stop to win, I'll take Polamalu, Reed, and Sharper starting over Meriweather, and assuming full health, I might even take Bob Sanders.
Don't get me wrong, I think the kid will turn out to be one hell of a safety, but would we be anointing him as the third best safety, and "knocking on the door" of dominance? I really don't think so. Lets knock off the reactionary crap and save these kinds of discussions for the end of the regular season, we'll need something to talk about during the Bye.
__________________
"It is better to be prepared and never have the opportunity than to have the opportunity and not be prepared." - Ted Marchibroda to Bill Belichick
|
|
|