PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
  • NEWS ▼
  • FORUM ▼
  • SCHEDULE
  • NFL ▼
  • STATS ▼
  • GAMES ▼
LOGIN | REGISTER
Home › Patriots Blog › Patriots Report Card
Patriots Report Card

Patriots Week 4 Report Card In 42-13 Win Over Carolina 

Steve Balestrieri
Steve Balestrieri Senior Writer · PatsFans.com since 2011
Sep 30, 2025 at 6:00 am ET · 5 min read · 3.4k views
Never miss a story
Follow Us on Google News Follow on Apple News Newsletter
Sep 28, 2025; Foxborough, Massachusetts, USA; New England Patriots wide receiver Stefon Diggs (8) runs with the ball while Carolina Panthers cornerback Mike Jackson (2) defends during the first half at Gillette Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Bob DeChiara-Imagn Images
Photo: Bob DeChiara-Imagn Images
5 min read Patriots Report Card

The Patriots had a lot of things go right when you beat an opponent 42-13. And that goes for any opponent. After falling behind 6-0 on Carolina’s opening possession, the Patriots regrouped, and then got their act together and played some outstanding football in all three phases.

So complete was their beatdown of a bad Panthers team, they outscored Carolina 42-0 until a late garbage time touchdown with Andy Dalton in at QB for the Panthers. After the scripted plays of Carolina had success, the defense regrouped and shut them down. 

The offense resembled a well-oiled machine with six different players scoring touchdowns and the team getting big chunk plays from all over the roster. They cruised to their first home win of the season, and it was a very good overall team effort. 

The grades will reflect that, as always.  

So, as we always do, let’s break it down by position

Quarterback: A

Drake Maye had another fantastic game. He had as many touchdowns (three, two passing and one rushing) as incompletions. For the third game in a row he completed more than 75 percent of his throws, which shows the command that he’s getting with the offense. 

He completed 14 of 17 passes for 203 yards (11.9-yard average), with two touchdowns, no interceptions for a passer rating of 155.6. His completion percentage on Sunday was 82.4 percent. 

I’m not going to nitpick the few throws that hit the ground (and neither should you). There was a guy here named Thomas Edward Brady who had off throws in games occasionally, but the other guys get paid too. This was a fantastic performance and he definitely seems like he’s on his way.

Running Backs: B

The running backs earned an “F” last week, but talk about a bounceback type of game. All three backs had nice chunk plays on the day. All three averaged more than four yards per carry on the day. 

Rhamondre Stevenson led the group in reps and carries (9 carries 38 yards, 4.2-yard average with a long run of 22. TreVeyon Henderson had seven carries for 32 yards (4.6-yard average) with a long of 11 and scored his first NFL touchdown. Antonio Gibson had six carries for 27 yards, with a long of 21 and scored a touchdown. 

What was even better about the effort is that the group was clean, no one put the ball on the ground. While no one’s stats blew you away, it was a very solid, group effort that did what they had to do. As a whole, the team ran for104 yards.

Wide Receivers: A-

Last week, we clamored for the team to move Stefon Diggs to the slot to open up the wide receivers’ production. Well, Diggs did move to the slot and had his first 100-yard game in two years, his first as a Patriot and the 37th of his career. 

Diggs and Maye are getting their chemistry down and he looked like the guy the Patriots were signing for this spring. His two big chunk plays, a 33-yarder and a back shoulder 30-yarder from Maye to set up the Patriots final touchdown were beauties. 

Mack Hollins scored his second touchdown of the season on a nicely designed play. Kayshon Boutte had only one catch for 18 yards. DeMario Douglas who barely played was singled out by Mike Vrabel for a good block that sprung Hunter Henry for a touchdown.

Tight Ends: A-

The Patriots’s tight ends are continuing their strong play. Hunter Henry and Austin Hooper are the most consistent, reliable players on the offense. Even though they were only targeted three times, they combined for three catches, 63 yards and a touchdown. 

Henry scored a 31 yard touchdown when he rolled across the formation when Maye rolled out to his left. It was a fantastic play. Hooper added a 24-yard chunk play of his own.  

Offensive Line:A-

The offensive line had one of its best games of the season. With Jared Wilson out with an injury, Ben Brown filled in nicely. The pass protection was very good, the run blocking was very good as well. 

And how about this… no false starts, no holdings, no penalties at all. That’s a nice game for Doug Marrone’s players. 

Defensive Line: B+

The defensive line, particularly Christian Barmore and Milton Williams have been outstanding this season. Vrabel mentioned how disruptive Barmore has been, despite not showing up on the stat sheet. 

But the inside duo along with Harold Landry and K’Lavon Chaisson were very disruptive to Bryce Young and the Carolina passing game. 

The run stopping was not as sharp this week as it has been for the first three weeks of the season. Give the Panthers’ backs some credit there, they made a couple of really nice runs. Chuba Hubbard had 49 yards on 10 carries, Trevor Ettiene had a nice 22-yard run as well.

But I also think from rewatching the tape, was that the Patriots had this one well in control and weren’t going to sweat too much allowing Carolina to run when they were down by several scores.

Linebackers: B

The linebackers were all around the ball again. Jack Gibbens replaced Christian Elliss and led the team with 12 tackles. Robert Spillane once again had a strong effort in the middle and had another 10 tackle game. 

Elliss did rotate back in with Marte Mapu and had nine tackles of his own, but I believe that he’s lost his starting position to Gibbens. Something to keep an eye on this week, is that Jahlani Tavai is eligible to return to the lineup.

Secondary: B+

The Patriots secondary overall had a very strong game. Carolina scripted its first 15 or so plays and Young was off to a very hot start, (more to this below). Bryce Young started 6-6 for 71 yards and a touchdown. 

After that, he was 12-24 for 79 yards for the rest of the game. That is an average of 3.29 yards per pass. They’ll take that all day long. With Christian Gonzalez back, the Patriots had their starters together for the first time this year. And it looked pretty good. 

Tetairoa McMillan had four catches for 62 yards on eight targets. He’s an outstanding young receiver, but he wasn’t a big factor in the game. Rookie safety Craig Woodson had a couple of nice third down plays but was victimized on the Panther’s first touchdown when he fell victim to a pick play. Overall, the secondary had a fine effort on Sunday. 

Special Teams: A

I don’t know that we’ve ever handed out an “A+” on these positional report cards, maybe during the Brady years, but I was close to doing so here this week. 

Marcus Jones gets player of the week honors with three outstanding punt returns. The first, an 87-yard touchdown, completely flipped momentum in the game to the Patriots. He later added a 61-yard return that was stopped when the punter got him by a shoelace. He added a 19-yard return in the fourth quarter. 

His 167return yards set a new Patriot record, breaking the Michael Haynes 156 yards set in 1976. 

Bryce Barringer averaged 51.9 yards per punt with a long of 59, but his 56-yard punt which was caught at the Carolina three-yard line by Ettiene, who was then tackled for a two-yard loss by Brendan Schooler. That’s how you draw stuff up. 

Coaches: A-

Mike Vrabel has to be thrilled with the effort this week. The team was dominant in all three phases of the game. That’s the kind of complementary football that he is looking for. Vrabel did mention that the team has to do a better job of defending the scripted plays at the beginning of games. And rest assured that will be a big topic of coaching this week. 

Zak Kuhr made the necessary adjustments to the defense after a slow start. Josh McDaniels called a great game and had the offense getting production out of everyone. Was it perfect? Nope, but this was the type of game that they can build off of moving forward. 

That’s it for the Panthers week, now the Patriots are traveling to Buffalo to take on the 4-0 Bills. They will have a much tougher task this week.

 

Follow me on Twitter @SteveB7SFG or email me at [email protected].

Listen to our Patriots 4th and 2 podcasts as the writers Russ Goldman, Derek Havens, and I from PatsFans.com discuss the latest Patriots news and game analysis.

 

Like this article?
Support Steve and buy him a coffee.
PatsFans.com — Independent Patriots Coverage Since 2000

Support Us: Help Us Compete Against The Corporate Media Giants

We need your help. If you enjoy our content, please help us beat Google's Corporate algorithm by adding us as a preferred source on Google News.

Click the button below and check the box next to "PatsFans.com"

Add as a preferred source on Google News
Read Next MORSE: Cleaning Out the Patriots Notebook 10/1 →
About Steve Balestrieri
Steve Balestrieri

A former US Army Special Forces NCO and Officer, Steve has been following the Patriots since their days at Fenway Park. Steve has worked in the film industry and wrote as an Military Editor at SpecialOperations.com, 1945.com as a reporter for the Millbury Daily Voice, Millbury-Sutton Chronicle, and the Grafton News. He's also a member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)

View all posts by Steve Balestrieri
Tags: Antonio Gibson Austin Hooper Bryce Young Carlton Davis Carolina Panthers Christian Barmore Christian Gonzalez Chuba Hubbard Drake Maye Harold Landry Hunter Henry Milton Williams New England Patriots Patriots edge rushers Rhamondre Stevenson Stefon Diggs Tetairoa McMillan TreVeyon Henderson Trevor Ettiene

guest

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
JimK
JimK
9 months ago

Bills are the proverbial “Litmus test” but this game is a tad early to cast judgements in stone. One team is stable as hell in their program, offensive and D systems are solidly in place. Coaches, QB, o-line are mostly all together for years. The Pats are a work-in-progress. The Pats are trying to play ball and absorb new systems and learn to play together as a unit. The Bills are purely executing. Good “gauge” game none the less.

0
Reply

📅 This Week in Patriots History:

From our archive - this week all-time:
July 2 - July 17 (Through 26yrs)

  • VIDEO: Mohamed Sanu Back In Massachusetts Working Out With Jarrett Stidham(2020)
  • VIDEO: Rob Gronkowski Vs Spicy Chicken Wings(2016)
  • Patriots Daily Notebook 7/9: Insider Doubts Top Defensive Free Agent, Amazing Gesture By Maye(2025)
  • Brady Makes 'Difficult Decision' To End Legal Process(2016)
  • A Free Agent Farm In Foxborough(2001)
  • New England Patriots Training Camp Primer (2017)
FULL ARCHIVE
📈 Recent Most-Read Articles:
1
2022 New England Patriots Draft Picks – Full List
2
2024 Patriots Draft Picks – FULL LIST
3
Patriots Announce Ticket Increase, Dropping Stadium Parking Fees
4
Tom Brady’s ‘Life Is Hard’ Speech: Full Patriots HOF Transcript
5
Heading Into Free Agency, Patriots Have Two Tough Player Decisions to Make
📰 Follow PatsFans.com
Follow Us on Google News Follow on Apple News Get the Newsletter
Right Now At PatsFans.com:
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis - 2026 Coaching Staff
2026 NFL Offseason:
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis - 2026 Coaching Staff
By: Mark Morse
  • MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis - Secondary
  • Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection

More Patriots News Headlines:

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – 2026 Coaching Staff

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – 2026 Coaching Staff

By: Mark Morse
The Patriots' 2026 coaching staff, including Mike Vrabel, Josh McDaniels, and Zak Kuhr, maintains continuity after their Super Bowl run.
24 hours ago
MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis – Secondary

MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis – Secondary

By: Mark Morse
Patriots positional analysis breaks down the 'best in the league' secondary, detailing Christian Gonzalez's contract, Marcus Jones's role, and Kevin Byard's 2026 impact.
3 days ago
Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection

Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection

By: Steve Balestrieri
Previewing the Patriots' pre-training camp 53-man roster projection, Christian Gonzalez, Sean Payton's Belichick offer, and Mac Jones' 2022 season.
5 days ago
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – Linebackers and Special Teams

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – Linebackers and Special Teams

By: Mark Morse
Patriots' Linebackers and Special Teams are analyzed, detailing player performances, contract years, and improvement areas for multiple players.
7 days ago
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis: Defensive Line

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis: Defensive Line

By: Mark Morse
Analyzing the Patriots' defensive line ahead of training camp, breaking down established veterans and promising young talent at defensive tackle and EDGE.
1 week ago

Free Newsletter

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW

Join 2,000+ fans getting exclusive stats, analysis, and insights delivered straight to their inbox every week. Never miss a play.

📊
Weekly Stats Deep-dive analysis
🎯
First Access New features & tools
📤
Breaking News Player Signings & Rumors

Subscribe Now

* required

Intuit Mailchimp

PatsFans.com Social Logo
PATSFANS.com

The longest-running independent New England Patriots site online since 2000. Not affiliated w/any school, team or league.

Resources

  • Patriots Forum
  • Schedule
  • Patriots Roster
  • Transcripts
  • Patriots Wiki Pages
  • Archive

Stats

  • Offensive Stats
  • Opponent Stats
  • Offensive Line
  • Snaps Overview
  • Penalties

Analysis

  • Snap Analysis
  • Personnel Groupings
  • Stats By Personnel
  • Top 10 Plays
  • Offensive Line
  • Defensive Totals

Site

  • About Us
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us

© 2000-2026 PatsFans.com

Privacy Policy Advertise RSS Feed
wpDiscuz