PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
  • NEWS ▼
  • FORUM ▼
  • SCHEDULE
  • NFL ▼
  • STATS ▼
  • GAMES ▼
LOGIN | REGISTER
PatsFans.com › Patriots Blog › Ian Logue › Regardless of Today's Outcome, Manning and Brady's Lega...
Ian Logue

Regardless of Today's Outcome, Manning and Brady's Legacy's Are Set

Ian Logue
Ian Logue Senior Writer · PatsFans.com since 2000
January 19, 2014  · 11:50 am | 3 min read | @IanLogue
Follow PatsFans.com
Google News ✉ Newsletter






By the time the Patriots and Broncos are done deciding who's moving on to New Jersey in two weeks, it's safe to say that this game will fall into the list of accomplishments for either Tom Brady and Peyton Manning, and nothing more.

Despite all the thoughts and opinions to the contrary this week, nothing that happens this afternoon, positive or negative, are going to sway the pundits one way or another to change the already deep seeded opinions that each player has spent more than a decade's worth of accolades and achievements establishing. Neither legacy will be affected by how today ends, and it's an argument that holds no merit. Both have had long careers and the opinions by the masses, right or wrong, have already been decided.

Everyone knows Tom Brady's legacy.  He took the NFL world by storm after winning three championships in his first full four seasons, and from there he's already piled up every accolade and record needed to build a legacy that everyone will ever remember long after he walks away from the game.  He's reached two other Super Bowls and fell just short, with one coming off of a perfect regular season. When he gets done with the game or the game gets done with him, his name will be enshrined in Canton and he'll forever be one of the quarterbacks that players coming into this league will aspire to be.

The same can be said for Manning, although his reputation is a little different.  Plenty of success in the regular season, having racked up some of the best passing totals in the league over the course of his career.  However, his playoff record hasn't exactly been stellar and his one Super Bowl came after besting New England's flu-infested 2006 club that ran out of gas in the second half of the AFC Championship game as the Colts managed a come-from-behind win, and then got the gift of playing a terrible Chicago Bears team to win his first Lombardi Trophy.

But a ring is a ring, and Manning has gotten his.  At the same time Brady already has three of his own, and looking back at what both players have accomplished, it's hard to argue that they've both already had a career that most other people in their position could only imagine.  One more ring for Manning is merely a consolation prize to help offset the 10-11 postseason record he currently holds and would put him one game over .500 at 12-11, provided he wins today to advance and again two weeks from now. He would also tie his brother, who has already bested the Patriots signal caller twice in order to get them.

Brady, meanwhile, is 18-7, giving him the best winning postseason percentage in league history.  With every yard he throws for Sunday, he'll extend his postseason all-time passing yard total a little higher after eclipsing the 6,000-yard mark during the Patriots win last weekend against the Colts.

At this point, he's playing with house money and has the benefit of going out on the field likely knowing that after everything his team has been through and all the losses they've sustained, they've still got just as good of a chance to move on as they've ever had.

For Manning, the entire media world has given the usual million reasons of why he should win.  To top things off, they're piling on a little more by saying his legacy is on the line and can change completely by beating New England this afternoon.

The truth is, his legacy won't change any more than Brady's.  The problems he's had in the playoffs will be rehashed every time his name is mentioned, while Brady's records and success over his career will be mentioned as well.  Brady winning a ring won't change what people already feel about him no more than the opinions people have of Manning, regardless of whether or not he's able to win another title.

Oddly enough, none of those successes or failures will help either player this afternoon, and the only story that will be written will be the outcome from today.  What's done is done, and they've both reached the point where regardless of who hoists the Lombardi trophy in two weeks, they've both already set the bar for the men who will someday replace them in the years to come.

They'll both always be remembered as two of the best to ever play the game. One game isn't going to change that.

This is an archived article originally published on January 19, 2014. Content reflects the editorial context of its original publication date.

More News Headlines:

MORSE: Looking At Patriots Wide Receiver Room and Gabe Jacas Mess

MORSE: Looking At Patriots Wide Receiver Room and Gabe Jacas Mess

By: Mark Morse
The Patriots' wide receiver room is under review, highlighting AJ Brown, Demario Douglas, and key battles. The Gabe Jacas controversy adds intrigue.
6 hours ago
Key Questions Remain After Patriots Mini Camp: Little Margin For Error at Several Positions

Key Questions Remain After Patriots Mini Camp: Little Margin For Error at Several Positions

By: Ian Logue
Reviewing Patriots minicamp, key questions remain for 2026 concerning the offensive line, linebacker, receiver depth, tight end, and Drake Maye's role.
2 days ago
Patriots News 06-14, Patriots Wrap Up Spring Workouts

Patriots News 06-14, Patriots Wrap Up Spring Workouts

By: Steve Balestrieri
Patriots wrap up spring workouts, looking ahead to training camp and the 2026 season. Drake Maye's development, A.J. Brown & Romeo Doubs boost offense.
3 days ago
Patriots Rookie Lomu Reveals “Weird” First Days at Right Tackle

Patriots Rookie Lomu Reveals “Weird” First Days at Right Tackle

By: Ian Logue
Patriots rookie Caleb Lomu details his 'weird' initial adjustment to right tackle after college, now feeling natural with veteran Morgan Moses' help.
5 days ago
Vrabel’s Goal For Christian Barmore in 2026: “Being able to finish”

Vrabel’s Goal For Christian Barmore in 2026: “Being able to finish”

By: Ian Logue
Vrabel challenges Christian Barmore to 'finish' plays and increase sacks in 2026. His season management is also detailed.
5 days ago

📈 Recent Most-Read Articles:
1
2022 New England Patriots Draft Picks – Full List
2
2024 Patriots Draft Picks – FULL LIST
3
Patriots Announce Ticket Increase, Dropping Stadium Parking Fees
4
Heading Into Free Agency, Patriots Have Two Tough Player Decisions to Make
5
Tom Brady’s ‘Life Is Hard’ Speech: Full Patriots HOF Transcript

📅 This Week in Patriots History:

From our archive - this week all-time:
June 2 - June 17 (Through 26yrs)

  • New England Patriots News 6-12, AFC East Notes(2016)
  • Mini Camp: A Look Back(2003)
  • Daily Patriots News and NFL Notes: 5 Things to Know - 6/3(2021)
  • Boyce Is Healthy And Ready To Produce For The Patriots(2014)
  • Thursday Patriots Notebook 6/8: News and Notes(2023)
  • ICYMI: Social Media Reaction To Romeo Crennel's Retirement(2022)
FULL ARCHIVE
Free Newsletter

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW

Join 2,000+ fans getting exclusive stats, analysis, and insights delivered straight to their inbox every week. Never miss a play.

📊
Weekly Stats Deep-dive analysis
🎯
First Access New features & tools
📤
Breaking News Player Signings & Rumors

Subscribe Now

* required

Intuit Mailchimp

PatsFans.com Social Logo
PATSFANS.com

The longest-running independent New England Patriots site online since 2000. Not affiliated w/any school, team or league.

Resources

  • Patriots Forum
  • Schedule
  • Patriots Roster
  • Transcripts
  • Archive

Stats

  • Offensive Stats
  • Opponent Stats
  • Offensive Line
  • Snaps Overview
  • Penalties

Analysis

  • Snap Analysis
  • Personnel Groupings
  • Stats By Personnel
  • Top 10 Plays
  • Offensive Line
  • Defensive Totals

Site

  • About Us
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us

© 2000-2026 PatsFans.com

Privacy Policy Advertise RSS Feed