PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
  • NEWS ▼
  • FORUM ▼
  • SCHEDULE
  • NFL ▼
  • STATS ▼
  • GAMES ▼
LOGIN | REGISTER
PatsFans.com › Patriots Blog › Ian Logue › Penalties On the Patriots Ended Up Being the Difference
Ian Logue

Penalties On the Patriots Ended Up Being the Difference

Ian Logue
Ian Logue Senior Writer · PatsFans.com since 2000
September 18, 2005  · 4:00 am | 5 min read | @IanLogue
Follow PatsFans.com
Google News ✉ Newsletter

CHARLOTTE, NC -- Make enough mistakes during a game in the National Football League and you'll lose.

Just ask the New England Patriots, who made more than their fair share on Sunday during their 27-17 loss to the Carolina Panthers.

Winning three of the last four Super Bowls, the New England Patriots had gotten pretty good at forcing mistakes by other teams and walking off the field victorious. People would talk about how the Patriots didn't beat that team, but that the other team simply beat themselves and that's the reason why New England won.

Well, now the Patriots are that other team.

Twelve penalties. Six false starts. Three turnovers. It's amazing they were even within the 10-point margin that they were after losing 27-17 against the Carolina Panthers on Sunday.

Each one of these miscues for the most part caused problems for New England.

The first penalty for New England came on the first play of the game. Matt Light was called for a false start which put the Patriots in a first and long right off the bat. An incompletion, a run for all of three yards by Corey Dillon, followed by another incompletion by quarterback Tom Brady lead to the first punt of the game for New England. It didn't seem like a big deal but it ended up setting the tone for the game.

On the ensuing possession rookie Logan Mankins would be the next Patriot called for a false start. Fortunately for Mankins Brady would later connect with Deion Branch on a 15-yard completion to offset the penalty. Luckily again no harm was caused by the miscue, but on Carolina's ensuing possession New England would finally get burned.

Facing a third and 10 at their own 33, Carolina quarterback Jake Delhomme was intercepted while trying to connect with wide receiver Keary Colbert by Patriots defensive back Duane Starks. What seemed like another timely turnover by the Patriots defense was quickly called back after linebacker Roosevelt Colvin was called for an 'illegal use of hands' penalty. While Carolina would end up being forced to punt it squandered what would have been terrific field position for the Patriots offense.

Thankfully Brady would connect with wide receiver Troy Brown on a miscue by Carolina. On the play the Panthers double-teamed Deion Branch on a slant and Brown, who was in the slot, drifted outside and was wide open. Brady found him and Brown scampered 71 yards before being hit by Ken Lucas on the play. The 34-year old Brown got up and walked away while Lucas stayed down. One play later Brady found Graham all alone in the endzone for the touchdown.

The Panthers would answer with a touchdown of their own, and after the two clubs traded punts another New England penalty would end up leading to points for the Panthers.

Facing a 2nd-and-1 at the Carolina 23, as you would have thought New England handed off to running back Corey Dillon who was stopped short of a first down. Unfortunately on the play Dan Klecko, who had come into the game to lead block for Dilllon, was called for an offensive holding penalty which backed New England up 10 yards. Now facing a second and 11 it forced Brady into a passing situation of which he was intercepted by Will Witherspoon. Had Klecko not committed a penalty, the odds are pretty good that the Patriots would have again run Dillon and either gotten a first down, or punted. Unfortunately the turnover gave the Panthers good field position and eventually lead to a field goal for Carolina.

On the ensuing kickoff Kevin Faulk was called for an offensive holding penalty, backing the Patriots up from their own 38 back to their own 26. In a game of field position New England would later punt, and a 76-yard punt return gave the Panthers the ball at the Patriots 13.

The next penalty gave the Panthers a touchdown instead of a possible field goal. Facing a 3rd and 7 at the Patriots 10 Eugene Wilson was called for pass interference in the endzone, giving the Panthers 1st and goal at the one. After that it took just one play for Carolina to punch it in and give them a 17-7 lead.

On the second play of the second half came New England's next penalty, with safety Rodney Harrison ripping off the helmet of Panthers running back Stephen Davis after meeting him in the backfield. It was a stupid penalty, and the 15-yard assessment helped put the Panthers in field goal range, with John Kasay booting a 52-yard field goal to put Carolina up 20-7.

The next penalty for New England thankfully didn't lead to any serious problems. Russ Hochstein was called for a false start, but luckily on the next play facing a blitz the Patriots called a screen pass and running back Kevin Faulk gained 22 yards. The play led to a field goal for New England.

On their ensuing possession Hochstein was again called for a false start, putting them in a first and 15. After two straight incompletions, it put them in third and long, and that allowed Carolina to blitz quarterback Tom Brady and force a turnover. On the play Panthers defensive end Mike Rucker hit Brady and forced a fumble, which was recovered by Julius Peppers. Four plays later the Panthers scored, putting them up 27-17.

An offensive holding penalty on New England's next play from scrimmage again made it difficult to mount a comeback. Dillon would be called for the holding penalty costing them 10 yards, and on the next play Daniel Graham would be called for a false start. It put the Patriots in yet another third and long and lead to a punt for New England.

Penalties. They're typically a big problem and as you can see were a problem yet again on Sunday. Mistakes typically lead to lost opportunities which eventually lead to the Patriots loss on Sunday. Brady told reporters after the game that both he and the rest of his team have plenty of work ahead of them.

"When you don't play well you're going to lose," Brady told the media after the game. "It's not like things correct themselves, you've got to go out there and work hard to correct them and that's what we've to start to do, starting tomorrow."

This is an archived article originally published on September 18, 2005. Content reflects the editorial context of its original publication date.

More News Headlines:

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – 2026 Coaching Staff

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – 2026 Coaching Staff

By: Mark Morse
The Patriots' 2026 coaching staff, including Mike Vrabel, Josh McDaniels, and Zak Kuhr, maintains continuity after their Super Bowl run.
1 day ago
MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis – Secondary

MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis – Secondary

By: Mark Morse
Patriots positional analysis breaks down the 'best in the league' secondary, detailing Christian Gonzalez's contract, Marcus Jones's role, and Kevin Byard's 2026 impact.
3 days ago
Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection

Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection

By: Steve Balestrieri
Previewing the Patriots' pre-training camp 53-man roster projection, Christian Gonzalez, Sean Payton's Belichick offer, and Mac Jones' 2022 season.
5 days ago
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – Linebackers and Special Teams

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – Linebackers and Special Teams

By: Mark Morse
Patriots' Linebackers and Special Teams are analyzed, detailing player performances, contract years, and improvement areas for multiple players.
7 days ago
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis: Defensive Line

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis: Defensive Line

By: Mark Morse
Analyzing the Patriots' defensive line ahead of training camp, breaking down established veterans and promising young talent at defensive tackle and EDGE.
1 week ago

📈 Recent Most-Read Articles:
1
2022 New England Patriots Draft Picks – Full List
2
2024 Patriots Draft Picks – FULL LIST
3
Patriots Announce Ticket Increase, Dropping Stadium Parking Fees
4
Tom Brady’s ‘Life Is Hard’ Speech: Full Patriots HOF Transcript
5
Heading Into Free Agency, Patriots Have Two Tough Player Decisions to Make

📅 This Week in Patriots History:

From our archive - this week all-time:
July 2 - July 17 (Through 26yrs)

  • Patriots 2019 Training Camp Guide - Wide Receivers(2019)
  • Tuesday Patriots Notebook 7/9: News and Notes(2024)
  • A Week's Worth of Patriots News(2010)
  • Myron Pryor Signs - Highlight Video(2009)
  • Patriots News 7-16, Kraft, Morgan Semi-finalists For Canton(2023)
  • WATCH: Cam Newton Meets Up With N'Keal Harry For First Workout Together(2020)
FULL ARCHIVE
Right Now At PatsFans.com:
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis - 2026 Coaching Staff
2026 NFL Offseason:
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis - 2026 Coaching Staff
By: Mark Morse
  • MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis - Secondary
  • Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection
Free Newsletter

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW

Join 2,000+ fans getting exclusive stats, analysis, and insights delivered straight to their inbox every week. Never miss a play.

📊
Weekly Stats Deep-dive analysis
🎯
First Access New features & tools
📤
Breaking News Player Signings & Rumors

Subscribe Now

* required

Intuit Mailchimp

PatsFans.com Social Logo
PATSFANS.com

The longest-running independent New England Patriots site online since 2000. Not affiliated w/any school, team or league.

Resources

  • Patriots Forum
  • Schedule
  • Patriots Roster
  • Transcripts
  • Patriots Wiki Pages
  • Archive

Stats

  • Offensive Stats
  • Opponent Stats
  • Offensive Line
  • Snaps Overview
  • Penalties

Analysis

  • Snap Analysis
  • Personnel Groupings
  • Stats By Personnel
  • Top 10 Plays
  • Offensive Line
  • Defensive Totals

Site

  • About Us
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us

© 2000-2026 PatsFans.com

Privacy Policy Advertise RSS Feed