tombonneau

This is an offshoot of the Caldwell thread. The final WR spot could very well come down to Caldwell vs. Gaffney. Let's assume it does, regardless of the scenario.

If you had the final say as the Pats final WR, Caldwell or Gaffney, who would you choose and why?

Again, we will disregard all other variables and have the choice a simple Caldwell vs. Gaffney.

g-fresh

How many threads have there already been about this?

pats1

Please refer to the Caldwell thread for my thoughts regarding the situation.

(In a nutshell, Caldwell. He is consistently solid throughout the season and into the playoffs. Gaffney has one great game the entire season. And you're telling me you'd rather have Gaffney?)

tombonneau

I don't know. I poke around the board a few times a day for news, but don't hae a logfile of every post.

("Working from home" today though, hence I'm a bit more active. )

spacecrime

If I had final say, I would have them compete in pre-season and choose the guy who did the best and gave us the best chance to win.

KontradictioN

Gaffney. He didn't have a great season stats-wise, but he really came on in the playoffs.

__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Grizzafted

Gaffney by far. No question. He's a gem.

DaBruinz

Really? Gaffney is a gem? Because of a couple of good games. Out of 11.

So, because Gaffney was finally able to put together a couple of good games, he's better than Caldwell?

Very interesting...

Amazing how little someone has to do to become a GEM...

Seymour93

Gaffney didn't have all TC, preseason, and the early part of the regular season to get used to the offense. And he wasn't thrown into the #1 WR role either. He stepped up big time in the playoffs, while Caldwell choked when it counted most.

__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Grizzafted

Yeah, I happen to think he's a real talent for the position he's supposed to be playing. He's a number 3 or 4 reciever, but he's got great hands and he runs very precise routes. I thought that it took him until the playoffs to get really familiar with the offense, but I'd certainly rather have him in the 4 spot right now over Kelly Washington or Chad Jackson.

When I said gem, I meant he's a guy who flew under the radar, not that he's some phenomenal talent. I would rather have him on the team than Caldwell.