Worst/Best assumed FA Trades Signings this year so far... - Page 2 - New England Patriots Forums

patsox23 · 03-23-2007, 07:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crowpointer

You just can't let this one go can you ? Hey I respect your opinion of arguing against Belichick and Pioli's expertise.

This is a thread about what we consider good and bad moves. I'm commenting on it. I didn't start the damn thread, I'm just weighing in.

Meanwhile, posters like you continue to misinterpret and mispresent my position. I don't like the deal, no, but the thrust of my argument was that some of you seem to think Welker IS something he has not yet shown himself to ACTUALLY be. WILL he be as good as you guys contend that he already is? I sure hope so. Seems like BB/Pioli think so. Hope they're right.

But please try harder to comprehend the not-at-all-confusing nuance of my argument.

patriotsdynasty12189 · 03-23-2007, 07:36 PM

The reason Alex Smith and Vince Young and Eli have big money is because they were all top 3 picks.

ChoWZa · 03-23-2007, 08:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by patsox23

This is a thread about what we consider good and bad moves. I'm commenting on it. I didn't start the damn thread, I'm just weighing in.

Meanwhile, posters like you continue to misinterpret and mispresent my position. I don't like the deal, no, but the thrust of my argument was that some of you seem to think Welker IS something he has not yet shown himself to ACTUALLY be. WILL he be as good as you guys contend that he already is? I sure hope so. Seems like BB/Pioli think so. Hope they're right.

But please try harder to comprehend the not-at-all-confusing nuance of my argument.

I agree here but I'm going on the assumption they have evaluated Welker enough to make a legitimate determination of his value. The deal is not a great deal from a fan's point of view IMO. Just hope they got it right.