The Official 'Trade Brady' Debate Thread - Do Not Start Another One

[jcdavey]

Originally Posted by Lifer

Yeah, Brady sucks!

well no, he's just very unproven x2

he's unproven ouside of the pats system and he's unproven since his severe injury

why would a team break the bank for that?

[jcdavey]

has any player ever left the belichik pats and done good ? lol

[Fencer]

As I've said in other threads -- at 37/8/9 you might dump a Montana, Favre, or Brady for a sufficiently good alternative. But not at 32/33.

[billdog3484]

NO NO NO. he will be 32 next year i believe. this thread should be eliminated


nbcsports.com Video Player

[DaBruinz]

Ian - I love this site dearly, but stupid threads like this should be relegated to the Practice Squad.

Also, the post from Lifer seem to have a similar ring to the ones done by PatsLifer. Coincidence? *shrug* Either way, the post have been friggin ridiculous.

[Lifer]

Originally Posted by DaBruinz

Ian - I love this site dearly, but stupid threads like this should be relegated to the Practice Squad.

Also, the post from Lifer seem to have a similar ring to the ones done by PatsLifer. Coincidence? *shrug* Either way, the post have been friggin ridiculous.

you are telling Ian the thread he created is stupid? nice.

[MoLewisrocks]

Originally Posted by Lifer

you are telling Ian the thread he created is stupid? nice.

The truth isn't always pretty.

[aluminum seats]

Cold Hard Football Facts

Cold, Hard Football Facts.com: Cassel on fire; Brady on the trading block?


Pretty much making every point I made in my thread......and putting to shame the meatheads here about certain questions just not being raised.

[Ungeheuer]

Originally Posted by BlitzFritz

As best I can tell, Dallas got 3 #1s and 3 #2s from Minnesota. Lets start with that.
Or lets say BB could get the three best Defensive starters from a worthy team. ILB. SS. DE.

the question that is interesting is this -- is that amount of compensation worth more than the difference between having MC on the field instead of TB.

think about it. stop ranting. think.

i guarantee that if MC continues to progress, Mr BB and SP are definitely thinking about it. they have shown NO QUALMS in doing what is best for the team, regardless of fan loyalties.

note above - i am NOT saying it will happen, nor that it should happen, but IF MC continues to progress, the possibility of the largest trade in NFL history becomes less theoretic.

I totally agree. I'm not saying it's the right move or the smart move. But they have to think about it, that's the point.

I understand the "this thread should be closed" reaction, but if Cassel keeps playing like this-- a big if -- they will have to think about it. They'd be crazy not to. Brady is the most expensive player on the team by far, is coming off a catastrophic injury, and has a younger, cheaper replacement coming up behind him. If this were some other player besides Brady -- if there was a young tackle coming up behind Matt Light, for instance -- you'd pick the younger guy without a second thought. Of course the difference is that Brady is a historically great player and the face of the franchise, so for that reason it's highly unlikely that he'd ever be traded. But if Cassel keeps improving this is going to become a real issue pretty quickly.

[ausbacker]

I simply don't understand how a majority of you can't see Ian started this thread as a means to keep all the other bull**** threads under control and in 1 thread as opposed to a myriad.

Perhaps a sticky is in order.