Yes, because that is actually something I must admit, I haven't really looked into as much, as I find it more difficult to actually compare "GM stats" (if those exist?) ...
From what I gather Polian ended up leaving the Colts in quite a mess ? (Or am I wrong ?)
According to what "facts" ? There are also "facts" stating the opposite ..., Yet (seemingly) according to you, it's "Only" the QB that Plays on a team ..., surprised how little some of you think about your coach/gm really ...
Hasn't BB been the "De-Facto" GM almost his entire tenure so far in NE ?
And I know the argument goes both ways ;-)
A question was posed and I gave my couple of "ører" (Danish for cents, but also means ears lol) on the topic ...
My main reason for putting Manning above Brady, is because I believe that Brady, in far more seasons have had a far better team surrounding him than Manning has had, add Belichick (whom you guys "seem" to give Way too little credit) to that, is why my opinion is as it is ...
But that doesn't...
I've never said Brady wasn't good, and doesn't produce ...
And I think that year was the first and only time that an 11-5 team didn't go to the play offs ?
"Brady vs Rodgers vs Manning" is the title of this thread ? Or did the thread title change ??? :rolleyes:
Why 2012 Season Proved Peyton Manning Is Better Than Tom Brady | Bleacher Report
Evaluating QBs: Peyton Manning is a Better Playoff Quarterback than Tom Brady › Outside the Hashes
Now I realize that there are also tons of articles stating the exact opposite, however, I'm just puzzled at...
LOL, you very well know that the Looking at the teams, NE has almost always fielded an overall stronger and more talented team than the Colts, ADD (probably the GoaT coach to that) to that mix, which is why I believe such as I do ;-) Hell, even Cassel was made to look good ;-)
Haha, you are Right, my phone is messing up ... I mean without Brady ofcourse ;-)
And I'm not a "Brady-hater", I just don't think he is better than Manning, that's all :-)
First; I'm not a "Tebowite", I'm a Packer fan
Second; My contention (and reason why I'm giving Manning the edge over Brady) is that I believe without Brady, NE most likely would - in *My* opinion - have won a couple of titles anyway, whereas I don't think it would hold true, had NE not had...
I'm not disputing the simplicity of the offenses Manning has been running both in Indy and now in Denver, however, I'm just saying in my opinion, between the above mentioned QBs, I'd give Manning the "edge" ... When (if?) Belichick and Brady is able to win a fourth title, I'd probably concede...
Eh ? I may be mistaken, but are you not the one getting upset ? He isn't saying Tebow is better than AH ..., just that Coming out of the Combine Tebow scored higher in the Drills (at the Combine) except in one ...
@ Demo - Wonder when CC is going to post ... ?
I'm probably going to get "smacked" now ... :rocker: lol, but here goes ...
I'm not a Manning fan, however, in the comparison of the above mentioned, I would say Manning above Brady above Rodgers ...;
I've always thought Brady "owes" alot of his succes to Belichick, mostly evident by the...
There is a HUGE, ASTRONOMICAL and vast difference between the situation which existed in Denver (Kyle Orton) and New York (The "Butt-Fumble). Both the mentioned QB's were awfull and played as such ...
The situation here is quite different, No one, is EVER going to question who is starting...
Not being an American, but wasn't the soft helmets they used in the 50's/60's (?) replaced because hard helmets provided better comfort (and protection) ?
I do agree with the sentiment, however, Unfortunately I think it will not happen ...
Child, please ...
Seriously ? This is your retort ? /sigh
If your assessment (sp?) is to be even remotely plausible and to have even a grain of truth to it, it would mean Way too many people would have to be in on it and that practically EVERY game EVERY season is rigged ..., oh btw the...
Why Thank you !!!
:D
Kidding aside, do you honestly think that highly of Sean Payton ?
Personally I'm a Packer, however, I've always had high regard for BB, - TB not as much (but that's for another thread another time) ;)
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.