Sean Smith CB Utah - Is there a thread about him yet?

[Box_O_Rocks]

Still and all folks, the one potential round 1 DB who matches patchick's profile to a 'T' is the other "Smith."

As to "tall" DBs: BB has brought them in before to play specific roles - Chad Scott, Lewis Sanders. He goes after physical DBs who have enough size to battle the giant WR and TE, and some experience to step into a game situation cold and play a specific role. If Sean Smith has all the profiled physical tools, he may be drafted to compete with Wheatley, Wilhite, and Hobbs, but he's handicapped by being a junior - I wouldn't be surprised if at some point draftniks like Mayock start mumbling about how he should have stayed in school and gotten a little more experience.

[patchick]

Originally Posted by Box_O_Rocks

Still and all folks, the one potential round 1 DB who matches patchick's profile to a 'T' is the other "Smith."

You betcha. Pending combine numbers, Mr. Alphonso is the living embodiment of the Pats CB profile.

[DW Toys]

Originally Posted by satz

He is too big for our system but on the other hand if we do play mayo and guyton we gain some speed in the LB and maybe can loose some speed in our defensive back.

Here we go again. The midget CB that is a must for the Pats because there are no CB's over 5'10" that have that "quick twitch". I am amused watching the "quick twichers" get beat down by Plex,.T.O., Colson and Fitzgerald and oh yeah, Moss.
That has really worked well for us the last few years as far as DBs go when we try to match up. That way too tall CB in Oakland is awful. That very weak CB Champ Bailey is way too tall at 6'.
I am not saying you are wrong about scheme Satz. You might be right. I just do not get the 5'8" CB. When has that worked? When Green retired from the Redskins?

I don't believe the Pats should go that smallCB route, but then who am I? They tried to draft Zack Bowman at 6' last year. Maybe there is hope.
DW Toys

[DaBruinz]

Originally Posted by DW Toys

Here we go again. The midget CB that is a must for the Pats because there are no CB's over 5'10" that have that "quick twitch". I am amused watching the "quick twichers" get beat down by Plex,.T.O., Colson and Fitzgerald and oh yeah, Moss.
That has really worked well for us the last few years as far as DBs go when we try to match up. That way too tall CB in Oakland is awful. That very weak CB Champ Bailey is way too tall at 6'.
I am not saying you are wrong about scheme Satz. You might be right. I just do not get the 5'8" CB. When has that worked? When Green retired from the Redskins?

I don't believe the Pats should go that smallCB route, but then who am I? They tried to draft Zack Bowman at 6' last year. Maybe there is hope.
DW Toys

Yes, the Plexico beat the Patriot down when he was matched up against a 5'9 INJURED CB... The Patriots could have put Samuel on him, but felt they didn't need to..

Terrell Owens, while having 6 receptions, was held to 66 yards and 1 TD. Not a great day for him.

Colston? He hasn't played against the Pats.

Fitzgerald? He's played against the Pats twice. Once in 2004. He had 5 receptions for 35 yards. I'm not sure if it was Poole or Law matched up against him. And it was only his 2nd game of his rookie year. This year, he had 3 receptions for 101 yards, including a 78 yarder. However that 78 yarder was a break down by the entire defense and can't be blamed on just one person.

So, while I agree that the Pats could be looking at a taller cornerback if he has the agility and technique, I think that you could have done a better job with your examples.

[CanadianPat'sFan]

Originally Posted by patchick

You betcha. Pending combine numbers, Mr. Alphonso is the living embodiment of the Pats CB profile.

I think the Combine will be the place where we all get to see how this kid moves and which DB's "Look good for our system". I love the NFL network's coverage as we get to see how these kids move. I think after the combine I will have more info on who I like for a first round DB but from what I have watched on film Sean Smith can play.

[Box_O_Rocks]

The National Football Post | Juniors On The Rise

CB/FS Sean Smith, Utah (6-3, 210)

NFL Player Comparison: Nnamdi Asomugha


Smith had a productive junior season, totaling five interceptions and eight passes defended. However, he saved possibly his best performance of the year for the Sugar Bowl, where he fared very well in man coverage against freshman phenom Julio Jones. Smith has a long, angular frame and possesses great bend and re-direction skills for a guy his size. At 6-3, Smith is an imposing press cover man with the ability to consistently re-route receivers and turn and run down the field. His flexibility for his size is unmatched, and he exhibits an ability to find the ball and go up at the highest point. Smith is considered a CB/FS tweener, and there are concerns about his re-direction skills in off-coverage. But much like Raiders 6-2 press corner Nnamdi Asomugha, if Smith is allowed to play mostly press coverage at the next level, he should do well. As of now, Smith is a bit of an unknown and is being looked at more as a second-round pick. But if he runs as well as expected (sub-4.5), I can’t see many teams passing on his tremendous upside in the first round.

[mayoclinic]

Originally Posted by patchick

You betcha. Pending combine numbers, Mr. Alphonso is the living embodiment of the Pats CB profile.

Why not both of them? Back to this thought in a minute. But first ...

There's no doubt Alphonso Smith is a great college player and has a lot of the attributes that the Pats look for at CB. He's gamey, very tough, plays with a chip on his shoulder, plays the run extremely well for a small guy, has good reactions, and has probably the best ball skills of any CB in the draft. BUT he's 5'8" and doesn't have blazing speed. His ceiling is probably Asante Samuel ... maybe Darryl Green, but he doesn't have Green's amazing speed and ability to compensate for mistakes. He's be a great 2nd round pick. But at 23? I'm not so sure.

Sean Smith, on the other hand, has 6'3" height and man corner ability with excellent ball skills. His ceiling is more like Nnamdi Asomugha, or ... dare I say it ... Sean Taylor?

Add 10 lbs. to Sean Smith and play him at FS, with his cover skills and ball skills, and I personally think he would have a much better shot of becoming the "next Sean Taylor" than Taylor Mays does. A lot of people were salivating at the idea of Taylor Mays in the Pats backfield, and wouldn't have considered Alphonso Smith to be even in the same league as a prospect.

If Sean Smith played for the USC hype machine he would be a concensus top 10 pick right now based on his unbelievable physical ability. We would all be dreaming about "what if" we could trade up to get him. He also has production. Patschick mentioned that Wheatley and DRC had a 11 picks in their college careers. Sean Smith had 9 in less than 2 seasons at CB. He would be ideal to put on the big WRs such as Plaxico Burress, Terrell Owens, and Chad Johnson, as well as on TEs such as Dustin Keller and Dallas Clark. Sean Smith and Meriweather could become what Sean Taylor and Laron Landry were turning into in Washington.

Which gets me back to ... why not both of them?

I could realistically see Sean Smith becoming a 1st round pick based on his upside, and Alphonso Smith slipping to the early 2nd based on his height. A team like Cleveland picking at #37 in the 2nd round and needing CB could jump all over him (imagine picking Aaron Curry at #5 and Alphonso Smith at #37 and reuniting them, and then a big running back like Brown from CT in the top of the 3rd to back up and eventually replace Jamal Lewis; Cleveland would suddenly be competitive again and people would start calling Mangini "Mangenius"). Take Sean Smith at #23 and then trade our 3rd to move up from #47 to the top of the 2nd round and pick up Alphonso Smith. (Maybe get Connor Barwin at #57 to round out my fantasty). If we resigned James and Lewis Sanders and picked up a reasonably-priced FA such as Jabari Greer (assuming Hobbs will leave after 2009; or just keep Hobbs) our secondary would look like:

- S: Brandon Meriweather, Sean Smith, James Sanders, Lewis Sanders
- CB: Alphonso Smith, Jabari Greer/Ellis Hobbs, Terrance Wheatley, Gerald Wilhite

Looks much better to me than what we had in 2008.

[Box_O_Rocks]

Originally Posted by mayoclinic

Why not both of them? Back to this thought in a minute. But first ...

There's no doubt Alphonso Smith is a great college player and has a lot of the attributes that the Pats look for at CB. He's gamey, very tough, plays with a chip on his shoulder, plays the run extremely well for a small guy, has good reactions, and has probably the best ball skills of any CB in the draft. BUT he's 5'8" and doesn't have blazing speed. His ceiling is probably Asante Samuel ... maybe Darryl Green, but he doesn't have Green's amazing speed and ability to compensate for mistakes. He's be a great 2nd round pick. But at 23? I'm not so sure.

Sean Smith, on the other hand, has 6'3" height and man corner ability with excellent ball skills. His ceiling is more like Nnamdi Asomugha, or ... dare I say it ... Sean Taylor?

Add 10 lbs. to Sean Smith and play him at FS, with his cover skills and ball skills, and I personally think he would have a much better shot of becoming the "next Sean Taylor" than Taylor Mays does. A lot of people were salivating at the idea of Taylor Mays in the Pats backfield, and wouldn't have considered Alphonso Smith to be even in the same league as a prospect.

If Sean Smith played for the USC hype machine he would be a concensus top 10 pick right now based on his unbelievable physical ability. We would all be dreaming about "what if" we could trade up to get him. He also has production. Patschick mentioned that Wheatley and DRC had a 11 picks in their college careers. Sean Smith had 9 in less than 2 seasons at CB. He would be ideal to put on the big WRs such as Plaxico Burress, Terrell Owens, and Chad Johnson, as well as on TEs such as Dustin Keller and Dallas Clark. Sean Smith and Meriweather could become what Sean Taylor and Laron Landry were turning into in Washington.

Which gets me back to ... why not both of them?

I could realistically see Sean Smith becoming a 1st round pick based on his upside, and Alphonso Smith slipping to the early 2nd based on his height. A team like Cleveland picking at #37 in the 2nd round and needing CB could jump all over him (imagine picking Aaron Curry at #5 and Alphonso Smith at #37 and reuniting them, and then a big running back like Brown from CT in the top of the 3rd to back up and eventually replace Jamal Lewis; Cleveland would suddenly be competitive again and people would start calling Mangini "Mangenius"). Take Sean Smith at #23 and then trade our 3rd to move up from #47 to the top of the 2nd round and pick up Alphonso Smith. (Maybe get Connor Barwin at #57 to round out my fantasty). If we resigned James and Lewis Sanders and picked up a reasonably-priced FA such as Jabari Greer (assuming Hobbs will leave after 2009; or just keep Hobbs) our secondary would look like:

- S: Brandon Meriweather, Sean Smith, James Sanders, Lewis Sanders
- CB: Alphonso Smith, Jabari Greer/Ellis Hobbs, Terrance Wheatley, Gerald Wilhite

Looks much better to me than what we had in 2008.

Greedy, aren't we?

[mayoclinic]

Originally Posted by Box_O_Rocks

Greedy, aren't we?

Why not, what are fantasies for?

But if fixing the secondary is really a top priority, it's not totally unrealistic. Sounds better right now than William Moore at #23 and a CB in the 2nd round.

[Box_O_Rocks]

Originally Posted by mayoclinic

Why not, what are fantasies for?

But if fixing the secondary is really a top priority, it's not totally unrealistic. Sounds better right now than William Moore at #23 and a CB in the 2nd round.

But what about Louis Delmas in round 1 with Clint Sintim and Connor Barwin in round 2 and Burnett in round 3?