IcyPatriot

I would love to see the Wonderlic scores of all the Bill Belichick draft picks who had problems with the playbook. Not as a knock on Bill ... just that I would think in the later rounds he must take a chance here and there and take someone with a lower score than his average draftee.

On the other side of the coin ... I bet his FA post draft signees are almost all players who would have a very high Wonderlic score if they had taken it.

One last thing ... I bet the Patriots have their own Wonderlic type test and I would LOVE TO SEE IT ... probably position specific and most of us would flunk I would think.

Boston Boxer

hey, the Waterboy was dumb but he could play some LB...he just used his tacklin' fuel

JoeSixPat

I'm with you - I think Young showed he very much can play in his rookie year alone - the Titans have a huge number of needs, and weren't exactly at full strength at WR either.

He certainly has not been the disaster those who looked at his mis-reported 10 on the Wonderlic predicted - which includes myself. Having watched more than a few Titans games myself he definately turned my opinion around on him.

I'm not putting him in Canton just yet, but I don't think he's a bust either. And while he might not be book smart I don't think that translates well to being football smart.

__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Terry Glenn is a cowgirl

Tests are very much up for debate.

What if you had anxiety on the day of the test?

What if you didn't eat before the test, and you clearly were in a haze at that point?

It's all up for debate in my opinion.

Gut instincts are WAY more important than tests.

patchick

What if you had anxiety on the day of the game?

What if you didn't eat before the game, and you clearly were in a haze at that point?

Wonderlic scores are just one more data point, quite useful in the context of everything else you know about the player. A low score is a legitimate concern to check out for positions with responsibility to make calls for an entire unit (e.g. ILB, C).

patriotsdynasty12189

And yet hes on the playing field busting his ass making millions, while your sitting on the computer making fun of him... hmmmmm.

__________________
the patsssssssss

dryheat44

Here's the thing about the Wonderlic....and it's probably the most important facet.

Every player and his agent knows what kind of questions are on the Wonderlic. Every player and his agent knows what day the test will be administered. The test can be studied for effectively.

Failure to do well on the Wonderlic is an indication that the player did not adequately prepare for it, and it is primarily for this reason that it is a red flag for GMs. Ryan Clady, for example, likely did not take the test seriously, as he figured he was going to be a top ten pick regardless. Personnel folks typically don't care for such a cavalier/complacent attitude.

__________________
When it's third and 10, you can have the milk drinkers and I'll take the whiskey drinkers every time. -- R.I.P. Max McGee

VJCPatriot

http://potencial.wordpress.com/2007/...derlic-scores/

I'm sure that the Jaguars are kicking themselves for drafting such a complacent player as Reggie Nelson who only scored a 12 on his wonderlic... NOT! 63 tackles, 5 ints, 1 sack, 1 forced fumble, and 11 PDs in his rookie season. He easily blew the doors of Meriweather and claimed the starting FS position right out of the gate.
http://www.nfl.com/players/reggienel...e?id=NEL617002

The lesson here folks is that overgeneralizing a football player's abilities based on a single test score is dangerous and just does not make a lot of sense. It's the same as saying Jerry Rice will never make it in the NFL because he only ran a 4.6 40.

__________________