Godwin is paid as a #1 WR because he is an #1 WR. And he had Brady. Cole Beasley had Allen. Williams had Herbert. All eliminated from the discussion as I said. I already said elite QBs is a disqualifier because elite QBs make WRs better. Jimmy G is no elite QB.
And even then, Beasely didn't consistently get 1,000 yards. He got close just one year and never got 1,000 yards. And Mike Williams has gotten two 1,000 yard seasons in his six year career.
And looked at the other guys to see if any had disqualifying factors like the #1 WR the year they got 1,000 yards was injured for a significant amount of time. Did any of the other guys have three years in a row where they had 1,000 yard seasons as you stated Meyers would or did they have one fluke 1,000 yard season?
So at least we can agree on one thing. It is riduculous to believe that Meyers is likely to get 1,000 yards in each of the next three years. You have been unable to find a single #2 WR who has done that without an elite QB or being an #1 WR quality WR themselves. I will concede it is possible that Meyers may have one year over the next three where he might get a 1,000 yards if you are willing to admit it is next to impossible that he get 1,000 yards in all three.