This is career opponent-adjusted AY/A value from @jumosq btw.
Mahomes and Wilson could make gains very soon.
I think that Wilson already belongs in the top ten. He's accomplished more in half of a career than some on the popular lists have in all of their's.
A few years ago, before Brady ended the debate for good, I saw 4 top 10 lists of the most clutch QB's of all-time.
Brady, Elway, Marino, Montana, Starr & Unitas made all four lists.
Graham, Staubach, Stabler & Young made three of the lists.
Aikman, Bradshaw, Namath & Manning made one list each.
I was lucky enough to have seen all of them except Graham but his record was outstanding.
I believe that Unitas suffers from a milder case of what hurts the GOAT NBA player, too many people doing the judging never saw him play.
I really marveled at how quick Marino got rid of the ball and have to lay some of the blame for his lack of a ring on coaching. The problem was the same for him as it is for many great QB's not named Brady. They think they can put the ball anywhere at any time and can come up with a bad TO.
Stabler would be a good addition to any top ten.
I'm not a big fan of Elway's but he did get a couple of rings. I just wouldn't put him that high on the list.