Difference was, JG was horrible in practice, but good in the preseason games. If you add Stidham’s practices AND preseason games, he had the best camp by any rookie since Brady.
Crazy thing is, Skip Bayless was saying last August/September, that Belichick was fast tracking Stidham. I replied to him on Twitter, that he was a moron (he is). But he was kinda right.
I think Belichick saw something in Stidham during camp/preseason. It kinda reminds me of 2001, I forget which book it was in, maybe Patriot Reign, but Belichick felt Brady was better than Bledsoe that year in camp, and was thinking about the QB situation, whether to start Brady over the 10 million dollar man (Bledsoe), the injury to Bledsoe helped Belichick with the decision.
If the Pats were desperate to get Brady signed, well they sure didn’t show that desperation. They had plenty of time to get a deal done (for example: Drew Brees). So I wonder if Belichick saw enough to be comfortable with Stidham as his QB.