Jimmy Garoppolites appreciation thread

Jimmy is good but I don’t doubt the reports that some in the Niners organization think Mullens is as good if not better.

Tony2046 said:

Two interceptions is an impact. Sorry

Click to expand...

One interception

No one counts brady int to the colts to end the 06 afc championship game

And frankly, the int last year on the one yard line against the cheifs when we coulda went up 14 to 0 was way worse than either of his today.

I know you arent holding that last int with the game basically out of reach and having to force down throws against him. Because that wouldnt indicate someone who doesnt have an agenda or anything.

LT85 said:

Kyle shanahan lost this game.

Click to expand...

The 49ers D Coordinator lost it....play of the game was that 3rd and 19 and for some dumb @$$ reason decided to call zone....Hill found a nice spot for a 1st down and stole the momentum in the process. A punt by KC there and game is over.

Froob said:

Jimmy is good but I don’t doubt the reports that some in the Niners organization think Mullens is as good if not better.

Click to expand...

Was keeping Brady the right decision? That's the question.

Tony2046 said:

You're shifting the goal posts.

I've never said anything negative about JG. I've only stated that keeping Brady over JG was the correct decision. And I was right. The Garoppolites were wrong. Plain and simple.

Click to expand...

If that’s the case then those people are the idiots. Brady was midway through an MVP season en route to a Super Bowl appearance, followed up by a Super Bowl win the following year. To argue they should’ve given that up for the unknown is preposterous. I love Jimmy and think he may end up with a ring but I don’t think his career ever amounts to anything in the same stratosphere as Brady.

festy1986 said:

One interception

No one counts brady int to the colts to end the 06 afc championship game

And frankly, the int last year on the one yard line against the cheifs when we coulda went up 14 to 0 was way worse than either of his today.

I know you arent holding that last int with the game basically out of reach and having to force down throws against him. Because that wouldnt indicate someone who doesnt have an agenda or anything.

Click to expand...

I am. Because every throw Brady made in 51 mattered just as much. One won a championship and the other lost. Plain and simple.

Tony2046 said:

Exactly what I stated.

Jimmy was handed a super bowl caliber team and choked the victory away.

Garoppolite nation has been telling me for over two years how trading JG was a mistake and now we know that it wasn't.

Click to expand...

We knew it wasn't a mistake the minute Brady led the comeback against Jacksonville. Maybe even before.

Tony2046 said:

I am. Because every throw Brady made in 51 mattered just as much. One won a championship and the other lost. Plain and simple.

Click to expand...

Brady lost 2 and Jimmy lost 1.

I mean I chose Brady every ****ing time too but it's insane to pin that loss on jimmy

Try the coaching and the officiating first.

203Pat said:

If that’s the case then those people are the idiots. Brady was midway through an MVP season en route to a Super Bowl appearance, followed up by a Super Bowl win the following year. To argue they should’ve given that up for the unknown is preposterous. I love Jimmy and think he may end up with a ring but I don’t think his career ever amounts to anything in the same stratosphere as Brady.

Click to expand...

I agree with everything you've said but apparently you have not been following the Garoppolite movement that has infested our forum over the last few years.

festy1986 said:

Brady lost 2 and Jimmy lost 1.

I mean I chose Brady every ****ing time too but it's insane to pin that loss on jimmy

Try the coaching and the officiating first.

Click to expand...

I pin it on a closed eyed Jimmy tossing up interceptions.

MrTibbs said:

The 49ers D Coordinator lost it....play of the game was that 3rd and 19 and for some dumb @$$ reason decided to call zone....Hill found a nice spot for a 1st down and stole the momentum in the process. A punt by KC there and game is over.

Click to expand...

Let's call it coaching in general then. KS not doing anything with 1.40 on the clock to end the first half and just generally playing conservativelly was a huge problem.

If you play to not lose, you derserve to lose.

Tony2046 said:

I pin it on a closed eyed Jimmy tossing up interceptions.

Click to expand...

First one yes

Second one just meh.

Kermit int way worse

festy1986 said:

Brady lost 2 and Jimmy lost 1.

I mean I chose Brady every ****ing time too but it's insane to pin that loss on jimmy

Try the coaching and the officiating first.

Click to expand...

I didn't watch any of the game, so maybe you can help me. Which coach or official threw the two SF interceptions?

Tony2046 said:

Was keeping Brady the right decision? That's the question.

Click to expand...

Yes because i saw some things from jimmy g that would concern me if i was a 49ers fan. He’s in the same category as a dak prescott or kirk cousins. He doesn’t put games away when you need him to do it. He was staring down wideouts which is a joke for a guy that has been the league for awhile now.

festy1986 said:

First one yes

Second one just meh.

Kermit int way worse

Click to expand...

Mahomes also is a better player.

Deus Irae said:

I didn't watch any of the game, so maybe you can help me. Which coach or official threw the two SF interceptions?

Click to expand...

Let's start with if you think bradys last int against the colts in 06 afc title game had any impact on the game before I engage.

Deus Irae said:

I didn't watch any of the game, so maybe you can help me. Which coach or official threw the two SF interceptions?

Click to expand...

Not only that but overthrowing a potential td and staring down his wideouts. I think the 49ers know what they have with jimmy g.

StockingAnarchyNumber12 said:

Mahomes also is a better player.

Click to expand...

Absolutely. By miles.

Also better than 2020 brady.

festy1986 said:

Brady lost 2 and Jimmy lost 1.

I mean I chose Brady every ****ing time too but it's insane to pin that loss on jimmy

Try the coaching and the officiating first.

Click to expand...

You don’t pin it all on him. You can’t. But he’s part of it.

festy1986 said:

Let's start with if you think bradys last int against the colts in 06 afc title game had any impact on the game before I engage.

Click to expand...

Unless there was a trade, and substitution, that I don't know about, Brady had nothing to do with who threw the two SF picks tonight.