NFL Honors thread

Ice_Ice_Brady said:

Edgerrin James over Richard Seymour? lolololol

Click to expand...

Typical. Not surprising in the least bit. Who would pick James over Seymour building a team?

sb1 said:

Edgerrin James in. Was never a first ballot guy but figured he would eventually.

Click to expand...

He’s not better than Fred Taylor or Corey Dillon.

Froob said:

Typical. Not surprising in the least bit. Who would pick James over Seymour building a team?

Click to expand...

1. Bill Polian
2. Other morons

Ice_Ice_Brady said:

1. Bill Polian
2. Other morons

Click to expand...

Ron Wolf.

Joey007 said:

He’s not better than Fred Taylor or Corey Dillon.

Click to expand...

Also benefitted from Fivehead.

Yet another year where we see all sorts of proof that these HOFs are a joke.

Polamalu in. Two spots open

I don’t think James is even really Hall of Fame worthy at all. No way he’s better than Seymour and Rodney.

sb1 said:

Also benefitted from Fivehead.

Click to expand...

Dillon had Akili Smith and Jon Kitna for the majority of his career.

Deus Irae said:

Yet another year where we see all sorts of proof that these HOFs are a joke.

Click to expand...

These days the top factor is whether they are part of the NFL Network broadcast team.

Froob said:

I don’t think James is even really Hall of Fame worthy at all. No way he’s better than Seymour and Rodney.

Click to expand...

He’s the classic difference between “NFL Star” and “Hall of Famer”. Or was.

Isaac Bruce in

sb1 said:

Isaac Bruce in

Click to expand...

Hall of Fame resume:

Career highlights and awards

• Super Bowl champion (XXXIV)
• 4× Pro Bowl (1996, 1999–2001)
• Second-team All-Pro (1999)
• NFL receiving yards leader (1996)
• Los Angeles Rams No. 80 retired

Don’t look if you don’t want to see spoilers.

edgerrin james is a HOFer ? Is this serious ?

Froob said:

I don’t think James is even really Hall of Fame worthy at all. No way he’s better than Seymour and Rodney.

Click to expand...

I've been on the Harrison-HOF wagon for a minute now.

1)Impact player on 2 SB teams.

2)Longevity. And was a great player for many years, didn't just hang around.

3)Stats. His #'s are as good as 99.9% of any S to ever play.

His reputation is probably hurting him but that's incredibly hypocritical imo. Dude was an enforcer and was one of the best ever at it. He played when the game was balanced and unforgiven between the hashes.
Not only that but again his #'s are so good. INT, Sacks, TFL, PD ... His versatility speaks and shows up through the stat sheet.

Him and Sey getting in will be huge. Brady & Gronk will surely follow.

We really need to push for Slater too. He has been top 3, the best at his position forever. I'd push for #75 too. Top 3, if not the best at his position for a long time.

Some owners and fans would like nothing more to pretend this era/run didn't exist.

Albert Breer

✔@AlbertBreer

AP Defensive Rookie of the Year: 49ers DE Nick Bosa. Third Ohio State player in 4 years to win that award.

Well deserved , now go win the SB !!

https://twitter.com/intent/like?tweet_id=1223730771892080642

Steve Hutchinson in. That’s all 5.

I can’t wait for Hines Ward and Dallas Clark to make the Hall before Rodney and Seymour