Our top 5 most valuable players so far

Tottie said:

Glad 1 Patriot made the list. Why do you even post here? Do you even like the team?

Click to expand...

Have you heard of sarcasm? I had ST from 93-2013 or 14, so yeah, I'm a BIG fan, so much so that I gave Krafty Bob probably $15,000-$20,000 of my money during my time as STH in tickets, playoff tickets, lots of $9 beer in the stadium, parking etc...

Can’t really go wrong with most of what I’ve seen here but here’s mine:

Gilmore
Edelman
Van Noy
Brady
Devin McCourty

203Pat said:

Can’t really go wrong with most of what I’ve seen here but here’s mine:

Gilmore
Edelman
Van Noy
Brady
Devin McCourty

Click to expand...

This seems reasonable. I just can't justify putting Bailey on that list he is not great this year (esp compared to last year).

Edit: nevermind last year it was Allen not Bailey dear lord.

neuronet said:

This seems reasonable. I just can't justify putting Bailey on that list he is not great this year (esp compared to last year).

Click to expand...

Bailey the punter? He’s a rookie.

FCB02062 said:

Have you heard of sarcasm? I had ST from 93-2013 or 14, so yeah, I'm a BIG fan, so much so that I gave Krafty Bob probably $15,000-$20,000 of my money during my time as STH in tickets

Click to expand...

Impressive resume. I was cheeky because I see your "brady test" comments and "OTA" comments. Then I see you don't like Kraft either. Must be a BB man! Either way no disrespect carry on!

Elijah said:

I appreciate Thuney but I don't know how anyone could include an OL on the list.

Click to expand...

Without Thuney...would we even have any offense?

neuronet said:

This seems reasonable. I just can't justify putting Bailey on that list he is not great this year (esp compared to last year).

Click to expand...

You are surely not talking about Bailey given that it is his first season ?

That being said.. in no particular order (except for Gilmore)

Gilmore, KVN, Thuney, DMac, Edelman

farn said:

Gilmore
Collins
KVN
DMac
Guy

All D.

Click to expand...

If you theoretically could only have two guys out of Collins, Guy, and Edelman, Edelman would be the odd man out for you?

Boger probably cost Gilmore a DPOY award and possibly Brady the TD record (first anyway). Good stuff.

Elijah said:

I appreciate Thuney but I don't know how anyone could include an OL on the list.

Click to expand...

He's been the best player on offense.

Take him away & Brady might have got killed 4 games ago. Think abt how the line has looked & could have if he missed time combined w Wynn/Andrews.

I get 11 & he's not far from 5 on my list but Thuney has been one of the 5-10 best players at his position for 2 years now. Definitely deserves that type of respect.

Trust me he'll sign a deal comparable or > Brooks who just got 56/30 guaranteed.

Ice_Ice_Brady said:

If you theoretically could only have two guys out of Collins, Guy, and Edelman, Edelman would be the odd man out for you?

Click to expand...

That is an excellent point. I suspect I would, like most others, go with #11 & Collins. I guess I added Guy there as someone who is exceeding expectations and who I feel is very valuable.

Like voters, I am swayed by “expectations”. Kind of like the fact BB could / should be coach of the year annually. But because voters look for someone who exceeded preseason projections, they give it to someone else.

Gilmore
KVN
Thuney
Bailey
JE 11

Honarable mentions to Jason Garrett, Freddie Kitchens, and Carson Wentz.

luuked said:

You are surely not talking about Bailey given that it is his first season ?

That being said.. in no particular order (except for Gilmore)

Gilmore, KVN, Thuney, DMac, Edelman

Click to expand...

Um right I was comparing to Allen. Dear lord I'm retiring as of now.