OT: Was Manningham's catch in SB 46 the correct call?

Patjew said:

Does this thread feel like a kick in the ****?

Why yes it does.

Click to expand...

Maybe Ian can punish the OP by only allowing the OP access to game day threads for the next 3 weeks.

Biffins said:

Click to expand...

That ends the ****ing game.

I mean, if you watch the video with your eyes closed I could see how you think it was not a catch.

I’d love to discuss this but my psychiatrist has made this a forbidden topic. They don’t like using trank darts on people for some reason

maust1013 said:

Then the OP hit what they were aiming at

Click to expand...

It’s kinda hard to miss TBH.

nabwong said:

Tell me more about this kick in the **** story.

Click to expand...

After a good dinner with fritto misto focaccia bianca and white ribolla wine this is not the right thread...

italian pat patriot said:

After a good dinner with fritto misto focaccia bianca and white ribolla wine this is not the right thread...

Click to expand...

I’d like some!

Can a mod move this somewhere else? @Ian ?

If only Tony Eason had completed a pass, they might have won Super Bowl XX.

AndyJohnson said:

Can a mod move this somewhere else? @Ian ?

Click to expand...

I'd think the7th ring of the practice squad forum would be appropriate...if there still was one

maust1013 said:

I'd think the7th ring of the practice squad forum would be appropriate...if there still was one

Click to expand...

So we have @Ian's inferno?
So which level?

IcyPatriot said:

So we have @Ian's inferno?
So which level?

Click to expand...

Pats Fanatic said:

Click to expand...

I felt that.

AndyJohnson said:

Can a mod move this somewhere else? @Ian ?

Click to expand...

Not until I re-read @Jangles immediate response a few more times. I don't want to sound negative against the OP, but that response was the funniest part of an otherwise irritating day at work. Almost spit my coffee all over my desk when I read it.

I understand wishing it could have been different, but it wasn't. Fortunately, this team has made it a little easier to finally forget after the most recent run. So like most people, I'm a little more over it. That first loss to them remains the most painful. The second at least has been washed away a bit to the point where I'm not finding myself thinking about it anymore. But that first one...that will sting forever

Patjew said:

It’s kinda hard to miss TBH.

Click to expand...

Sorry to hear that.

everlong said:

Unlike the Tyree catch which was lucky as all hell on about 20 different levels ...

Click to expand...

You just know that Tyree's catch will be number one....

Elijah said:

Guys...what if uh...there was holding on the helmet catch

Click to expand...

... and not one of their "celebrity" commentators will mention the holding. Not that it matters now.