PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

2019 Roster Turnover


Status
Not open for further replies.
The Patriots had the largest amount of roster turnover in a long time with 23 new players, compared to Labor Day weekend 2018. That doesn't count players on suspensions like Watson and Kendricks, or players on NFI or short-term IR like Harry or Meredith.

23 is a lot of a 53 man roster, and the most since I looked back five or six years. The 2018 Patriots had 14 new players on their Labor Day roster. But other years have seen 20 or 21 new players as well. The Patriots really turn over the roster each year.

Let's look at some of the changes:

QB
In: Jarrett Stidham
Out: Brian Hoyer

RB
In: Damien Harris, Brandon Bolden
Out: Jeremy Hill

WR
In: Josh Gordon, Demaryius Thomas, Jakobi Meyers, Gunner Olszewski
Out: Chris Hogan, Cordarrelle Patterson, Riley McCaron, Chad Hanson

TE
In: Matt LaCosse, Ryan Izzo
Out: Rob Gronkowski, Dwayne Allen, Jacob Hollister

OL
In: Isaiah Wynn, Korey Cunningham, Jermaine Eluemunor, Russell Bodine
Out: Trent Brown, LaAdrian Waddle, David Andrews, Brian Schwenke

DL
In: Byron Cowart, Michael Bennet
Out: Malcom Brown, Trey Flowers, Adrian Clayborne

Edge/LB
In: Chase Winovich, John Simon, Jamie Collins, Shalique Calhoun
Out: Derek Rivers, Keionte Davis, Nicholas Grigsby, Geneo Grissom

CB
In: Joejuan Williams
Out: Eric Rowe, Keion Crossen, Duke Dawson

Safety
In: Terrence Brooks, Obi Melofonwu
Out: Brandon King

Punter
In: Jake Bailey
Out: Ryan Allen
The Patriots had the largest amount of roster turnover in a long time with 23 new players, compared to Labor Day weekend 2018. That doesn't count players on suspensions like Watson and Kendricks, or players on NFI or short-term IR like Harry or Meredith.

23 is a lot of a 53 man roster, and the most since I looked back five or six years. The 2018 Patriots had 14 new players on their Labor Day roster. But other years have seen 20 or 21 new players as well. The Patriots really turn over the roster each year.

Let's look at some of the changes:

QB
In: Jarrett Stidham
Out: Brian Hoyer

RB
In: Damien Harris, Brandon Bolden
Out: Jeremy Hill

WR
In: Josh Gordon, Demaryius Thomas, Jakobi Meyers, Gunner Olszewski
Out: Chris Hogan, Cordarrelle Patterson, Riley McCaron, Chad Hanson

TE
In: Matt LaCosse, Ryan Izzo
Out: Rob Gronkowski, Dwayne Allen, Jacob Hollister

OL
In: Isaiah Wynn, Korey Cunningham, Jermaine Eluemunor, Russell Bodine
Out: Trent Brown, LaAdrian Waddle, David Andrews, Brian Schwenke

DL
In: Byron Cowart, Michael Bennet
Out: Malcom Brown, Trey Flowers, Adrian Clayborne

Edge/LB
In: Chase Winovich, John Simon, Jamie Collins, Shalique Calhoun
Out: Derek Rivers, Keionte Davis, Nicholas Grigsby, Geneo Grissom

CB
In: Joejuan Williams
Out: Eric Rowe, Keion Crossen, Duke Dawson

Safety
In: Terrence Brooks, Obi Melofonwu
Out: Brandon King

Punter
In: Jake Bailey
Out: Ryan Allen
I agree that 11-5 was a "down year"...but remember the small things like:

a.) Making ONE ST tackle @ Miami.

b.) Brady making one of the dumbest throws of his career @ Pittsburgh.

c.) Looking ahead to the BYE week @Nashville and being uncharacteristically terrible @ Detroit.

The only legit loss was @ Jacksonville...we wilted in the heat down there and got our asses beat. But if you flip any of those 4 games...we are 12-4...the best record in the AFC.
The Patriots had the largest amount of roster turnover in a long time with 23 new players, compared to Labor Day weekend 2018. That doesn't count players on suspensions like Watson and Kendricks, or players on NFI or short-term IR like Harry or Meredith.

23 is a lot of a 53 man roster, and the most since I looked back five or six years. The 2018 Patriots had 14 new players on their Labor Day roster. But other years have seen 20 or 21 new players as well. The Patriots really turn over the roster each year.

Let's look at some of the changes:

QB
In: Jarrett Stidham
Out: Brian Hoyer

RB
In: Damien Harris, Brandon Bolden
Out: Jeremy Hill

WR
In: Josh Gordon, Demaryius Thomas, Jakobi Meyers, Gunner Olszewski
Out: Chris Hogan, Cordarrelle Patterson, Riley McCaron, Chad Hanson

TE
In: Matt LaCosse, Ryan Izzo
Out: Rob Gronkowski, Dwayne Allen, Jacob Hollister

OL
In: Isaiah Wynn, Korey Cunningham, Jermaine Eluemunor, Russell Bodine
Out: Trent Brown, LaAdrian Waddle, David Andrews, Brian Schwenke

DL
In: Byron Cowart, Michael Bennet
Out: Malcom Brown, Trey Flowers, Adrian Clayborne

Edge/LB
In: Chase Winovich, John Simon, Jamie Collins, Shalique Calhoun
Out: Derek Rivers, Keionte Davis, Nicholas Grigsby, Geneo Grissom

CB
In: Joejuan Williams
Out: Eric Rowe, Keion Crossen, Duke Dawson

Safety
In: Terrence Brooks, Obi Melofonwu
Out: Brandon King

Punter
In: Jake Bailey
Out: Ryan Allen
We are probably in for a similar year next year. We have about 20 contracts that
expire and the Patriots have not been re-signing as many players as prior years.
 
I agree that 11-5 was a "down year"...but remember the small things like:

a.) Making ONE ST tackle @ Miami.

b.) Brady making one of the dumbest throws of his career @ Pittsburgh.

c.) Looking ahead to the BYE week @Nashville and being uncharacteristically terrible @ Detroit.

The only legit loss was @ Jacksonville...we wilted in the heat down there and got our asses beat. But if you flip any of those 4 games...we are 12-4...the best record in the AFC.

I almost clicked the disagree button. Cherry-picking is not allowed. All of those plays count.
Plus the Patriots won a game or two that they easily could have lost. Imagine their final record if the experienced a bad bounce or two against Houston, KC, or Chicago.

"You are what your record says you are." ~ Bill Parcells
 
When you put it this way, you can really see how big the upgrades and downgrades were at certain positions. We look to have gotten much better at WR, EDGE and much worse at TE, OL.
 
I agree that 11-5 was a "down year"...but remember the small things like:

a.) Making ONE ST tackle @ Miami.

b.) Brady making one of the dumbest throws of his career @ Pittsburgh.

c.) Looking ahead to the BYE week @Nashville and being uncharacteristically terrible @ Detroit.

The only legit loss was @ Jacksonville...we wilted in the heat down there and got our asses beat. But if you flip any of those 4 games...we are 12-4...the best record in the AFC.
Lol
 
When you put it this way, you can really see how big the upgrades and downgrades were at certain positions. We look to have gotten much better at WR, EDGE and much worse at TE, OL.
Much better at edge is a stretch to me. I'd probably say we got a lot better at linebacker though.
 
Wonder if it’s normal for a Super Bowl champ to turn over 40+% of its roster the following year.

It's necessitated partly by the recent draft struggles. Take a look at the Patriots recent drafting in rounds 2 + 3:

JAG
Richards
Grissom
Jones
Thuney
Brissett
Valentine
Rivers
Garcia
Dawson


There's only one player on that list who's both with the team and starting/active, and that's Thuney. That's led to stopgap players taking the place of what should have been developing players who would stick with the Patriots for a relatively long term.
 
Closely related while out and about yesterday doing errands, overheard on the Radio... "Is K'Neal Harry a bust??" on both local sportstalk radio stations.. WTF so now if a 1st round pick gets hurt in a sport where a lot of folks get hurt, that is the criteria for success or failure of that pick??

Wish someone anyone would try discuss the Pats intelligently instead of trying to "gin up" some faux controversy... Sportstalk used to inform, now it enters into the realm of hysteria...

I'm surprised you expected anything other than this from local sports radio as this has been the staple for a few decades now. You can get reasoned opinions from some national NFL podcasts; that's what I tend to listen to.
 
I am not scared of the 40 percent roster turnover. While I think that is a bit much in any given year, I also think this team needed some new blood.

Outside of gronkowski, flowers and maybe brown, it is hard to see how we are not improved in these other replacements.

The real job ahead is can bb and the coaching staff mesh these guys into a cohesive unit good enough to win a suprbowl?
 
I am not scared of the 40 percent roster turnover. While I think that is a bit much in any given year, I also think this team needed some new blood.

Outside of gronkowski, flowers and maybe brown, it is hard to see how we are not improved in these other replacements.

The real job ahead is can bb and the coaching staff mesh these guys into a cohesive unit good enough to win a suprbowl?

I think you've missed a couple of possibilities, though I'm not saying that they're definite downgrades. I'm just pointing out legitimate possibilities based upon things like injury, experience, talent, etc...:

  1. Center position (Bovine for Andrews) is a possible downgrade
  2. WR position (Hogan/Patterson gone, Thomas, Meyers in) may/may not be a downgrade
  3. TE could be weaker at both TE1 and TE2, not just TE1
  4. DT seems thin, so if 2019 Shelton isn't significantly better than 2018 Shelton, the DT position will be a downgrade
 
Wonder if it’s normal for a Super Bowl champ to turn over 40+% of its roster the following year.
Regarding the Patriots, I've been thinking about this a lot. The Pats have a strong core (clearly, TB12 sets the tone) then go looking for value acquisitions or where possible, service major needs. Every year, the team turns over a decent percentage of its roster and every year, they keep performing. You can't help but wonder if this is by design as it keeps players from falling into the mindset of accepting good performances instead of being great, a keep them keen approach.
 
Those that are Out who I wished had stayed In:
- Hoyer, Waddle, Dawson

I know Gronk is doing what's right for him but from a purely selfish perspective I'd have him on any list of "Those that are Out who I wished had stayed In"
 
I agree that 11-5 was a "down year"...but remember the small things like:

a.) Making ONE ST tackle @ Miami.

b.) Brady making one of the dumbest throws of his career @ Pittsburgh.

c.) Looking ahead to the BYE week @Nashville and being uncharacteristically terrible @ Detroit.

The only legit loss was @ Jacksonville...we wilted in the heat down there and got our asses beat. But if you flip any of those 4 games...we are 12-4...the best record in the AFC.

The only one I can give you here is the Miami game which really was just a combination of freaky accidents so your point about 12-4 definitely stands.

That being said I think the losses against Detroit and the Titans were absolutely legit. We got outplayed as the team was not anywhere near gelling yet.. as is often the case earlier in the season.


You can't just apply the level they played at in the playoffs to the beginning in the season. And yet if something goes wrong on Sunday some people here will immediately compare this year's W1 team to the one that won the SB last year and say "this doesnt feel like the 2018 team".
 
When you put it this way, you can really see how big the upgrades and downgrades were at certain positions. We look to have gotten much better at WR, EDGE and much worse at TE, OL.

Much worse at OL ?

Potentially taking a step back is more appropriate with C being unexpectedly reworked due to Andrews' health scare but apart from that the only significant thing that happened is the depth being reworked.

Wynn might have some early issues (as did Brown last year) but I don't really expect there to be a substantial difference.
 
Wonder if it’s normal for a Super Bowl champ to turn over 40+% of its roster the following year.

Unheard of. The other 31 GM's don't have the stones. Of course David Andrews and Brandon King were forced changes.
 
QB - wash
RB - better
WR - better
TE - worse
OL - worse
DL - wash
LB - better
DB - better
ST - wash

3 units remained the same, 4 improved and 2 got worse. Overall this should be a better team than last year. It heavily relies on the health of Gordon though. If he does **** up again, a strength becomes a weakness.
 
QB - wash
RB - better
WR - better
TE - worse
OL - worse
DL - wash
LB - better
DB - better
ST - wash

3 units remained the same, 4 improved and 2 got worse. Overall this should be a better team than last year. It heavily relies on the health of Gordon though. If he does **** up again, a strength becomes a weakness.
Well, Harry is pretty much a back up for Gordon....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Monday Patriots Notebook 4/15: News and Notes
Patriots News 4-14, Mock Draft 3.0, Gilmore, Law Rally For Bill 
Potential Patriot: Boston Globe’s Price Talks to Georgia WR McConkey
Friday Patriots Notebook 4/12: News and Notes
Not a First Round Pick? Hoge Doubles Down on Maye
Thursday Patriots Notebook 4/11: News and Notes
MORSE: Patriots Mock Draft #5 and Thoughts About Dugger Signing
Matthew Slater Set For New Role With Patriots
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/10: News and Notes
Patriots Draft Rumors: Teams Facing ‘Historic’ Price For Club to Trade Down
Back
Top