Rodney Harrison makes Patriots HOF

Triumph said:

Mcourty is nothing special.

Click to expand...

lol wtf! That's all I can say. I don't even want to legitimize this absurd statement with a response arguing to the contrary. This is beyond belief.

Give me a break.

Gumby said:

sorry, I just can't take the rest of your argument seriously, even though it may have some sense, because the bold part is such horse-hooie. Rodney was not just an enforcer, he was smart and a coach on the field. To argue he couldn't adapt to the pay-me-ton/Gotohell(-chicks dig the long ball) rule changes is just absurd. Especially with BB as his coach.

Click to expand...

Again, you are looking at things through rose-tinted glasses. The reality is that none of the early 2000 teams would have a realistic chance against their 2010 counter parts. The NFL in which players like Harrison can be impact players doesn't exist anymore.

And the same is true for safeties. DMac is at least as smart and a coach on the field as Rodney was. In addition he can also play many more positions at a higher level that Rodney would be able to. Most of the things that made Rodney special are less relevant or straight not allowed anymore.

I don't get why everyone gets so defensive about the players on the teams that started the dynasty. They were great for their era but time has moved on and the game has become more complicated, more athletic and more strictly called.

Before Revis? Interesting.

363839 said:

idk...Sey left us. Rodney retired with us.

Click to expand...

Seymour didn't leave us.

Yeah yeah..I have read this from several posters. Fact of the matter is, as I recall, He was looking for more money. That's why he was traded. So yeah..he kinda did leave us.

They traded Seymour to Oakland because he wanted a big pay day. He didn’t “leave” per se.

luuked said:

Again, you are looking at things through rose-tinted glasses. The reality is that none of the early 2000 teams would have a realistic chance against their 2010 counter parts. The NFL in which players like Harrison can be impact players doesn't exist anymore.

And the same is true for safeties. DMac is at least as smart and a coach on the field as Rodney was. In addition he can also play many more positions at a higher level that Rodney would be able to. Most of the things that made Rodney special are less relevant or straight not allowed anymore.

I don't get why everyone gets so defensive about the players on the teams that started the dynasty. They were great for their era but time has moved on and the game has become more complicated, more athletic and more strictly called.

Click to expand...

Let's agree to disagree. Eras are no doubt different, I just disagree that Rodney wasn't adaptable. And I didn't mean to sound "defensive."

Isn't the better comparison to Chung?

BelichicksHoodie said:

They traded Seymour to Oakland because he wanted a big pay day. He didn’t “leave” per se.

Click to expand...

yep he forced their hand.

All three of them deserve to get in the Patriots Hall of Fame. I agree with those who’ve stated the Patriots should induct more than one in a given year when appropriate. Not enough to water down the status of getting into the Hall, but enough so that those who deserve to be in can get inducted in a more timely manner.

Julius.


Adams.

Rodney Harrison was the most emotional, inspired and playmaking player on our defense during the first phase of the dynasty. His "hit people in the mouth" mantra made watching the Pats on D just awesome. He got 2 picks in the first Philly Super Bowl including a game clincher. Awesome.

DarrylS said:

McCourty is nothing special?? Strange comment about a very good player who has only missed 5 games in a 9 year career, and has similar leadership qualities comparable to Harrison. He is not as vocal as Harrison, but nonetheless a smart player, a leader and role model.

Click to expand...

Hey, he only made 2nd Team All-Pro at two different positions.

maust1013 said:

Actually 'we' left Sey
I voted Sey but Rodney certainly belongs. Congrats to him!

Click to expand...

Let this be a lesson, don’t get traded!

PATSYLICIOUS said:

Let this be a lesson, don’t get traded!

Click to expand...

And stay on Bill's good side...just in case. Cause there's trades (Oakland) and then there's banishments (2016 Browns)

luuked said:

I don't get why everyone gets so defensive about the players on the teams that started the dynasty. They were great for their era but time has moved on and the game has become more complicated, more athletic and more strictly called.

Click to expand...

That's the game changer. Harrison probably still would be a great player if he was playing today, but he'd be a player like much more like McCourty than how Harrison was.

robertweathers said:

Moss was arguably the greatest talent to ever call Foxboro home...

Click to expand...

Arguably the second greatest
The greatest talent ever to play in any NFL stadium is still calling the one in Foxboro home.

maust1013 said:

Arguably the second greatest
The greatest talent ever to play in any NFL stadium home is still calling the one in Foxboro home.

Click to expand...

Frankly, I'd place him after Brady and Gronk.

PP2 said:

Frankly, I'd place him after Brady and Gronk.

Click to expand...

I'd place him after Brady, Gronk and Hannah. IMO Gronk is the greatest TE ever, and Hannah is the greatest interior OL ever (Munoz is generally considered the greatest tackle). You can only put Moss in that company if you call him the greatest WR ever. You can make that claim but I still rate Rice higher.

I voted for Sey but really happy that Rodney got in.