Rachelle's attorney said they did not contact Randy's attorney first, but that Randy's people called and offered a hundred thousand dollars. If this was the case and rachelle had not thought about extortion why would they even negotiate. Either they would turn down any offer because of the principle of the matter(violence), or they would have jumped at the unexpected offer. To end up negotiating after a ridiculously high offer is made doesn't make sense, especially throwing numbers out that are ludicrous. The only realistic scenario is that her lawyer is after cash all along, that's why she went to the hospital after she saw her lawyer, why she filed a restraining order instead of charges, and why he sees it as a half million dollar gift horse!