Who will have the worse career as a QB: JaMarcus Russell or Tim Tebow?

[Feep50]

He has 88 TDs to 16 INTs, the same as Sam Bradford, I think he can throw a little better than you're giving him credit for.

We shall see shortly, won't we........

 

[Snake Eyes]

We shall see shortly, won't we........

Yes, but I wonder if the impression that 'he can't throw' is due to his throws looking relatively unpleasant.

 

[billdog3484]

dumbest question on this board, clearly biased, go somewhere else

 

[SyN65]

Russell has surpassed Ryan Leaf as the biggest bust of all time, so no.

 

[PATRIOTSFANINPA]

Where Jamarcus wins this contest is the lovely assortment of expensive jewelry he was able to buy by stealing boatloads of money from Uncle Al for a job he was supposed to do....play as an actual Pro QB

Speaking of the Raiders ...Is there a possibility that Al could try and draft Tebow in round 1? - remember Hayward Bey as #7 last year...nothing is impossible in Raiduz country

 

[ctpatsfan77]

If Tebow doesn't play a snap at QB (or even minimal snaps), I would say Russell would then have had a better QB career.

Given that Oakland could arguably have fared better by not using a quarterback at all than by using Russell, I'm not sure that's true. . . .

 

[JoeSixPat]

Jamarcus should be the NFL Ambassador to China.

He's got more chins than a Hong Kong phone book.

 

[Patriot Missile]

He has 88 TDs to 16 INTs, the same as Sam Bradford, I think he can throw a little better than you're giving him credit for.

One of the most impressive college careers ever. And I'm pretty sure he is not going to get crushed coming out of the pocket if the play is designed right. Did anyone watch a Florida game over the last few years? As soon or if rather, he steps on the field for any team he would be one of the best scrambling QB's right away. He's got great vision for finding the holes.

I'm not promoting him as the Patriots first round pick.{I'd be dissapointed if that happened}I just think he does add value to a team if trained and used right. I think he will be a lot better than Pat White and if taken in the 2nd round will be a much higher value as well.

 

[Snake Eyes]

Speaking of the Raiders ...Is there a possibility that Al could try and draft Tebow in round 1? - remember Hayward Bey as #7 last year...nothing is impossible in Raiduz country

This would be interesting, if Davis grabs Tebow because of his combine numbers hoping him to turn the franchise around, immediately throws him in as QB where he proceeds to suck, and then gets bored with him and trades him to us next year in exchange for a 7th.

The other possibility is we trade #22 to Jacksonville in exchange for a ton of picks.

 

[patchick]

This would be interesting, if Davis grabs Tebow because of his combine numbers hoping him to turn the franchise around, immediately throws him in as QB where he proceeds to suck, and then gets bored with him and trades him to us next year in exchange for a 7th.

I don't get it. If the rookie QB he drafted too high struggles, shouldn't he just fire the coach?

 

[Snake Eyes]

I don't get it. If the rookie QB he drafted too high struggles, shouldn't he just fire the coach?

He'd fire the coach anyway but he'd also get a 7th, I mean just look at Edelman, imagine the talent Davis could pick up with that 7th

 

[patsfan55]

Have we ever seen this lopsided of a vote?!?