I got about halfway through the is Caldwell done thread and I couldn't take any more. So I figured I wanted just a straight answer to a simple question to help me make up my mind about Caldwell: Half the team was supposedly sick with flu that day. 15-20% couldn't hang out there in the 2nd half. Does anybody know if Caldwell was sick that day too? Was he just trying to hold it together out there while holding his lunch down and lost concentration for a minute????? Part b of question: If so; would that get any sympathy with the "lynch caldwell now crowd"? While I am disgusted about him dropping the pass and also not just breaking straight down the field when he was uncovered and letting TB just lay one out there for him.......I prefer to reserve judgement and let the professionals tell me if he sux or not on 1 Jun cut downs or 53 man roster cut downs. BB will watch him in action; I don't have that luxury. The guy caught above the league average # of passes last year and if it was Stallworth #1, Caldwell #2 and #3 Welker I would not be upset. So I give him benefit of doubt.