Discussion in 'PatsFans.com - Patriots Fan Forum' started by Miguel, Sep 24, 2010.
Team game: SN panel selects top 100 NFL players - NFL - Sporting News
Some quite frankly laughable placings there, like Polamalu at #39 and behind Ed Reed? I've only got that far down the list and I'm already shaking my head at some of the picks!
It's a bad list
I'd be interested in knowing how this was compiled. The selection panel is pretty distinguished, but I doubt that each one of them came up with a list of "1--100." Does any one know how it was done?
I think it might be a "bad ranking," but most of the names belong on the list. I'm interested in how they came up with the rankings.
Ware and Brady too low, Peterson is too high, and is Thomas is not that much better than Long. They seem to really favor last year over everything else. For example, see Dumervil's ranking based on just 1 good season. They would have been better off putting all the players in the same bucket and not numbering it.
Separate names with a comma.