You're using a bunch of drunken buddies as your "evidence", and you're bagging on my post?
Here you go, chief, more content than you've posted in the past 6 months or so....
1.) Brady is the team's best player, so giving him the ball is a good thing. Shotgun gives him a clearer field and more time to make his read.
2.) You, like so many other perfect playcallers, confuse making a call you don't approve of with making a bad call. They aren't necessarily the same thing.
3.) On the previous Patriots drive, which ended in a field goal, the Patriots went into the shotgun 3 times. One resulted in a 9 yard completion, one resulted in a 3 yard run, and one resulted in an incompletion because Edelman couldn't hang on to the ball, but should have resulted in a touchdown. In other words, the shotgun was working just fine.
NFL Game Center: Indianapolis Colts at New England Patriots - 2010 Week 11
4.) The only sack of the day came on a play where Brady was under center.
NFL Videos: Colts defense, sack, 8-yd loss
I realize that facts can be pesky things when they undercut your argument, but try them out anyway. If you want something to gripe about, gripe about Brady not taking the clock down more before snapping the ball.