Suspect drafting past few years

Discussion in ' - Patriots Fan Forum' started by SCPatBoy, Dec 6, 2009.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. SCPatBoy

    SCPatBoy On the Game Day Roster

    I don't think the Pats have done a very good job in the draft over the last 3 years. outside of Mayo, and he is probably Overrated to this point, what impact players have come out of the draft? I mean it seems as if we passed on alot of players who have turned out to be impact players for other teams to only secure future draft picks every year while only drafting depth players, and yet our team seems to get worse and worse. Especially the defense and the Offensive line. Our Secondary is suspect, and it seems several corners chosen after Butler are performing better to this point. We have no Pass Rush to speak of and I don't see any immediate help there. Our O Line gets beat consistently by 3 man rushes and I cant count the number of quality O lineman we have passed over. These past draft classes are really starting to give me flashes of the Bobby Grier days. I don't think we are any longer smarter then the rest of the guys when it comes to talent evaluation as we seem to have missed alot more then we have hit the Target lately.
  2. pats1

    pats1 Moderator Supporter

    Huh? 2009: Chung, Butler, Brace, Vollmer, Tate, McKenzie, Ohrnberger, Bussey, Ingram, Pryor, Edelman, Richard.

    That's at least one solid starter (Vollmer), five solid contributors (Chung, Butler, Edelman, Ingram, Pryor), two injured guys (Tate, McKenzie), and four developmental guys (Brace, Ohrnberger, Bussey, Richard).

    The only real question mark to this point is Brace. And personally, I think he'll make in impact in 2010 after this front seven is restructured.

    Yes, the 2006-2008 drafting sucked. Outside of Mayo and Meriweather, it was terrible. But the 2009 drafting did not.

    I addressed this topic a few months back:
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2009
  3. Jimke

    Jimke In the Starting Line-Up

    Right on. The trouble is that the 2006-2008 draftees should be filling

    some of the starting positions.

    PATSYLICIOUS Pro Bowl Player

    #12 Jersey

    This year has potential to be a great one.

    2007 we got Merriweather, Welker, Moss, hard to complain about that output.

    2008 we get Mayo, Wilhite both starters and Guyton as a UDFA he contributes.

    It's hard to complain considering we are typically towards the bottom end of each round.
  5. pats1

    pats1 Moderator Supporter

    Last edited: Dec 6, 2009
  6. pats1

    pats1 Moderator Supporter

    We're talking about actual draft pick selections here. I wouldn't count Moss, Welker, and Guyton. We're talking about the guys that the Pats decided to pick when they were on the clock.
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2009
  7. mayoclinic

    mayoclinic Supporter Supporter

    2009 was a fabulous draft. 2003-2005 were very good drafts. We got excellent value at the #32 position in 2005, which was the weakest draft of this decade - Mankins, Hobbs, Sanders, Cassel, and an extra 3rd in 2006.

    Our 2006-2008 drafts had issues, as far as I am concerned:

    1. 2006. Maroney was an OK pick, but he hasn't overwhelmed. The trade up for Chad Jackson bombed. Dave Thomas did nothing for us in 3 years at TE, and Garrett Mills was cut. O'Callaghan and Jeremy Mincey weren't particularly good picks. Gostkowski was by far our best pick. We could have picked up guys like TE Owen Daniels, DE Ray Edwards, DE Mathias Kiwanuka, WR Greg Jennings, CB Richard Marshall, and RB Maurice Jones-Drew.

    2. 2007. Meriweather was a fine pick, and trading #28 for what turned out to be Mayo and Moss was brilliant. Trading our 2nd round pick for Welker was equally brilliant. But the rest of the draft stunk.

    3. 2008. Mayo was a terrific pick. Trading #69 for a 2009 2nd round pick was also brilliant, though less so if Ron Brace turns out to be a dud. The result of the draft has been underwhelming - Terrance Wheatley at #62, Shawn Crable at #78, and Kevin O'Connell at #94 in particular. Jonathan Wilhite has done OK for a 4th round pick. Matt Slater was a reach. Gary Guyton was a steal as a UDFA.
  8. DocE

    DocE Third String But Playing on Special Teams

    I thought it was telling that after the "left behind" inactives (presumably due to injury) the only two healthy inactives were 2nd round picks Wheatley and Brace. The Pats have also gotten no production from two third round picks in O'Connell and Crable from '08 and another 2 3rd rounders, McKenzie and Tate from '09. Obviously injuries are a big factor with 3 of the 4 recent 3rd round picks, but it's still a disappointing lack of production. The failure to hit on any of the late round picks in the '07 draft also hurts. You can't expect to hit on many of those guys, but the Pats had a ton of picks in round 4 and later in '07 and none of the players panned out.
  9. As of right now, Vollmer has the most promise and the rest are a bunch of question marks. Their drafting since 2005 has been pretty bad. I've said this many times and have gotten ripped for it. The trading out works when you had veterans still contributing like McGinest, Vrabel, Bruschi, Colvin and Harrison. However, the Pats have made a trend in trading out of the rounds when they're clearly weak at several positions. Delaying the future (trading away draft picks) but picking up veterans instead has put them in the position they are today. Their defense is an absolute mess and the O-line needs help.

    At this point, I'm not too excited about Mayo and agree he may be overrated. He doesn't offer much other than tackling ball carriers 3-5 yards after the line of scrimmage. I rarely see this guy doing anything else. However, It might be their weak scheme that is holding him back.

    Don't get me wrong, I've been wanting fresh blood at LB for quite some time, but I didn't agree with taking a LB like Mayo with the 10th selection.
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2009
  10. FredFromDartmouth

    FredFromDartmouth In the Starting Line-Up

    There is a new sheriff in town and Pioli is off to KC. This is a rebuilding year...
  11. That's the problem, they have been rebuilding since '05 and they still have the same holes they have today.
    Last edited: Dec 6, 2009
  12. pats1

    pats1 Moderator Supporter

    Mayo may not be putting up sack or INT numbers, but he has the maturity level and work ethic of a 10-year vet. He's exactly the type of player BB looks for.
  13. The_Riddler

    The_Riddler 2nd Team Getting Their First Start

    Agree big time. Mayo is very overrated, no impact plays, nothing at or behind the LOS for stuffs and not that great in coverage. I really don't see anything to get excited about, he's very, very mediocre. If someone sees something else or has seen something else with Mayo please point out the opponent and the play, because I haven't.

    Again with the 10th overall pick we still could have traded down 5 more slots, picked up another 3rd or 4th round pick and drafted the guy we should have drafted in the first place to replace Asante and that is DRC. The next great NFL shutdown. Again, I think it's time for BB to take off the personnel hat and turn it completely over to a more qualified guy whether that be completely over to Floyd Reece or bring someone in from the outside. BB's FA signings and draft day decisions have been real head scratchers to say the least.
  14. Deus Irae

    Deus Irae Retired Jersey Club Supporter

    Disable Jersey

    You can't honestly evaluate a draft without taking trades into account. Moss and Welker are a part of that draft, for example.

    Having said that, for all the complaining that goes on about those drafts, here's how the whining is misplaced. Just a glance at 2006 has


    still collecting NFL checks.
  15. SoonerPatriot

    SoonerPatriot In the Starting Line-Up

    Maybe Bobby Greir is available.
  16. The_Riddler

    The_Riddler 2nd Team Getting Their First Start

    And these All World players still collecting NFL checks indicates exactly what ?
  17. The_Riddler

    The_Riddler 2nd Team Getting Their First Start

    Bobby Grier might be an upgrade :)
  18. SoonerPatriot

    SoonerPatriot In the Starting Line-Up

    I'm not ready to go there yet, but give it a few more weeks (losses). :)
  19. OldNEPatsFan

    OldNEPatsFan Practice Squad Player

    Have you actually watched the past two games an seen the tackles Mayo has missed. He is way overrated.
  20. The Intimidator

    The Intimidator On the Game Day Roster

    2005: Logan Mankins and Dan Koppen.

    2006: Laurence Maroney and Stephen Gostkowski.

    2007: Merriweather and no one else.

    2008: Mayo and two corners who have been ineffective.

    2009: Great across the board.

    Take a look at this and non aggressiveness in free agency, no wonder why this team is struggling the way they are. Have one, two, 3 at best in the draft. This is why. It isn't Moss or Wilfork. It is the inability in free agency and the draft. Sometime the scouting needs to be questioned.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page