JackBauer
Hall of Fame Poster
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2005
- Messages
- 25,365
- Reaction score
- 7,823
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.LOL Because that's all clowns like you got...:bricks:
Well...my issue is why fit any of them in...although the BOB issue (as opposed to what the thread has been hijacked into as usual) is at least relevant.
Sign me up, it was a mistake to let Peppers go to the Bears.
Having a player of William's caliber improves the entire defense.
First win the superbowl, next piss everyone off by adding two 1st round picks and Mario Williams.
BRAVO!! :rocker:
Super Mario ~ as discussed by Brother Jay and others, elsewhere ~ is a SuperBEAST!!
Those who judge his IMPACT based on Sacks betray a COMPLETE ignorance of this Great Game.
If we could ~ because of Planet Hoosten's Cap Issues ~ get him for FREE...
It would be the Coup of the Century!! :rocker:
Mario would be sweet! Either as 4-3 DE or 3-4 OLB, I'd expect he'd be a beast.
Whether the question we need more than one guy, he would help immensely.
I mean, the secondary really doesn't need much more help in 2012, with Mccourty/Arrington/Dowling at CB next year, Chung at S, and Moore at CB/S, the team really just needs one good safety next to Chung. A player like Mario would make them all better too.
It's impressive how many sacks Carter and Anderson got this year. But let's be real...Mario Williams is a different beast and would improve the pass rush in a BIG way. A team's pass rush shouldn't be judged based on the number of sacks. It's about pressure. Sometimes you get the sack, sometimes you don't. But it's the pressure you want.
Would you rather have a pass rush that gets you 2 sacks in a game and no pressure the rest of the game. Or a pass rush that gets no sacks, but is getting consistent pressure, QB hits/hurries throughout the game?
Who sez that Carter and Anderson and Ninkovitch weren't getting pressures as well as sacks?
Nothing is free... We can get anyone we want, but as Bill often reminds those of us who listen there is a tradeoff. We have other needs, and we have a pair of TE's we probably won't even be able to hang on to because they won't stay for free... Mario spent most of this season on IR. At a cap hit in excess of everyone on this roster except the QB. They've already paid him $54M and have nothing tangible to show for it until they brought in a cagy old DC who finally schemed them at least to a division title and the playoffs without Mario even factoring into the equation...
They did more than scheme, they evaluated talent and made investments in their defense. Wade Phillips is a really good defensive coach (not much of a head coach) but any coach needs players.
The good news for the Patriots is that Houston went from 267.5 passing PYG against to 189.7. The bad news is that they had a good foundation to draw from.
NFL Stats: by Team Category
2011
1st round pick - JJ Watt, DE
2nd round pick - Brooks Reed, DE
2nd round pick - Brandon Harris, DE
Sign CB Johnathan Joseph
Sign S Daniel Manning
2010
1st round pick - Kareem Jackson, CB
2009
1st round pick - Brian Cuhing, LB
2nd round pick - Connor "the legend" Barwin, LB
2007
1st round pick - Amobi Okoye, DT
2006
1st round pick - Mario Williams, DE
2nd round pick - Demarco Ryan, LB
National Football League: NFL Draft History - by Team
Unfortunately for us we don't have the luxury of picking that high in drafts.
I NEVER SAID THEY WERE.
My response was directed at the claim that Williams hasn't posted double digit sacks in a while, and Anderson and Carter have. That statement questioned the impact Williams would have only because he didn't "have double digit sacks".
My point was to show that sacks are an over rated stat and Williams would have a huge impact.
Also, I never said it would be wise to spend a ton of money on a guy like Williams. Again, I was just pointing out that he would have an impact, and to discount that impact only because he hasnt had double digit sacks in a while is wrong.
They did more than scheme, they evaluated talent and made investments in their defense. Wade Phillips is a really good defensive coach (not much of a head coach) but any coach needs players.
The good news for the Patriots is that Houston went from 267.5 passing PYG against to 189.7. The bad news is that they had a good foundation to draw from.
NFL Stats: by Team Category
2011
1st round pick - JJ Watt, DE
2nd round pick - Brooks Reed, DE
2nd round pick - Brandon Harris, DE
Sign CB Johnathan Joseph
Sign S Daniel Manning
2010
1st round pick - Kareem Jackson, CB
2009
1st round pick - Brian Cushing, LB
2nd round pick - Connor "the legend" Barwin, LB
2007
1st round pick - Amobi Okoye, DT
2006
1st round pick - Mario Williams, DE
2nd round pick - Demarco Ryan, LB
National Football League: NFL Draft History - by Team
I find the claims made in your post to be a two-way street. I made it pretty clear in my original post that I have a high opinion of Mario. If you think that I am downplaying his abilities; I'm not. It's just that I have a high opinion of Carter too. Carter (especially when paired w/ Anderson) really wasn't much worse than what Mario would provide.
You argued that "Mario Williams is a different beast and would improve the pass rush in a BIG way." Well, I disagree in a big way. Is he a better player? Sure. But pass rush - with Carter + Anderson - wasn't the problem with this D. Nor was it the problem in Hou in 2010 when their D was the worst in the NFL. So yeah, acquiring Williams (and giving up high drafts picks + way too much cap space) isn't the way to fix this D.
Sooo...Because we need more than one guy, we should ignore ALL improvement?? :bricks:
...Including acquiring one of the best 5 players in the GAME???
You might want to reconsider your thinking, there, old sport.
What if he wasn't franchised and the cost was cap money?