Fencer
Pro Bowl Player
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2006
- Messages
- 14,293
- Reaction score
- 3,986
When making up candidate rosters, we usually don't leave enough room for the specialist players who wind up making it.
So let's take a look at a hypothetical 53, plus game day actives, while accounting for such guys. I'll assume:
It would be fairly comfortable to say that that includes:
QB (3) -- Obvious ones, 1 inactive.
RB (3) -- Obvious ones, all active. This is a little light even with a FB, but so be it.
TE (3) -- Obvious ones, all active.
WR (5) -- Lloyd, Welker, 3 others (e.g. Gaffney/Branch/Stallworth), 1 inactive.
OT (4) -- The one who isn't Vollmer/Solder/Cannon inactive.
Interior OL (5) -- Waters/Koppen/Connolly/Gallery active, one younger/less established guy inactive.
That's 23 total/19 active on offense, leaving 22/19 for defense.
CB (5) -- McCourty, Dowling, Arrington, Moore, Dennard
S (4) -- Chung, Wilson, Gregory, other, 1 inactive
ILB/LB (4) -- Mayo, Hightower, Spikes, Fletcher, 1 inactive
LB/DE (3) -- Ninkovich, Jones, Bequette
Lighter pure DL (3) -- Fanene, Pryor, Warren, 1 inactive
Heavier pure DL (3) -- Wilfork, Love, Deaderick/Brace
That's 22 total/19 active. The numbers balance!!
Notable cuts include:
Edit: Scott. Every time I make one of these lists I completely forget about Scott.
IR could save a couple of guys. So, of course, could skimping at WR, but my base case is that BB keeps a lot of the vet contenders, then doesn't replace whichever one falls by the wayside as the season progresses.
So let's take a look at a hypothetical 53, plus game day actives, while accounting for such guys. I'll assume:
- Slater makes the roster.
- Edelman makes the roster.
- White makes the roster.
- Another ST-focused LB makes the roster (Koutivides/Tarpinian).
- A fullback makes the roster.
- K/P/LS are on the roster (duh).
- Kick returners can be found from among position players and/or the above.
- Andre Carter and Logan Mankins aren't on the opening roster, and by the time they join the team they're taking spots from guys who have been IRed.
- I'm correct that 46 is the current number of game day actives.
It would be fairly comfortable to say that that includes:
QB (3) -- Obvious ones, 1 inactive.
RB (3) -- Obvious ones, all active. This is a little light even with a FB, but so be it.
TE (3) -- Obvious ones, all active.
WR (5) -- Lloyd, Welker, 3 others (e.g. Gaffney/Branch/Stallworth), 1 inactive.
OT (4) -- The one who isn't Vollmer/Solder/Cannon inactive.
Interior OL (5) -- Waters/Koppen/Connolly/Gallery active, one younger/less established guy inactive.
That's 23 total/19 active on offense, leaving 22/19 for defense.
CB (5) -- McCourty, Dowling, Arrington, Moore, Dennard
S (4) -- Chung, Wilson, Gregory, other, 1 inactive
ILB/LB (4) -- Mayo, Hightower, Spikes, Fletcher, 1 inactive
LB/DE (3) -- Ninkovich, Jones, Bequette
Lighter pure DL (3) -- Fanene, Pryor, Warren, 1 inactive
Heavier pure DL (3) -- Wilfork, Love, Deaderick/Brace
That's 22 total/19 active. The numbers balance!!
Notable cuts include:
- Chad Johnson
- Cunningham
- The losers in various position battles I've noted above
- The late-round picks (PS fodder)
- Various vets from other teams (Allen, Carpenter, Gonzalez)
Edit: Scott. Every time I make one of these lists I completely forget about Scott.
IR could save a couple of guys. So, of course, could skimping at WR, but my base case is that BB keeps a lot of the vet contenders, then doesn't replace whichever one falls by the wayside as the season progresses.
Last edited: