I think the problem people have with this article is not necessarily the content, but the Patriots fan’s view of the source and media in general. I have always enjoyed and respected SMY's work. I have never viewed as a reporter with any sort of agenda and still don’t. But the fact that this maybe one AD article too many from a reporter who obviously has a good working relationship with AD, and it is from the Globe, a publication that between Borges, Shaughnessy, and now Massarotti and Gasper has built up some bad blood with Patriots fans over the years. is the reason for the strong reaction from Pats fans. In other words, if the same words were written by someone like Curran or Reiss, I don't think people would be having the same reaction.
I think another part of the reason Breer (Hernandez case) and SMY have received some unwarranted venom (going beyond criticism) is because of the Globe's recent past, along with a rising tide of over the top anti-pats shtick in the media since 2007, which has given many Patriots fans every right to be a little sensitive:
-Spygate and its ludicrous over-exaggeration and fallout, which has subjected Patriots fans to "cheating" accusations everywhere since (I always use the "its legal from the endzone/pressbox, we just did it from the sidelines, what the big deal, do your research, or do they not teach reading in Pittsburgh?)
-The continued vilification of our coach by the national media, who are forever bitter about his unquotability and desire to give out injury information.
-The post-spygate rise of national analysts who have become more obvious in their anti-Patriots bias (Tom Jackson, Marshall Faulk, Charlie Casserly, Mike Ditka, Mike Golic, Steve Wyche, and countless others).
-The Tomase/Herald/Walkthrough travesty
-The advent of a new sports radio station that spews slanted, misinformed anti-Pats slander from 6-10am, 2-6pm, and 6-11pm. (yes, you 98.5. Tony Massarotti must be stopped)
The point is SMY is getting unfairly criticized for this article. But it is not necessarily because us Patriots fans are whiny little brats. It is no small part due to the work of many of her colleagues throughout the football/Boston media landscape who have created a tremendous and warranted level of skepticism from Patriots fans.