Should NFL remove players from HOF?

Discussion in ' - Patriots Fan Forum' started by JR4, May 8, 2010.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. JR4

    JR4 In the Starting Line-up Supporter

    The NFL is suppose to representative of the best the NFL has had.
    When a player commits a crime or brings great disgrace to their name
    and that player in Canton HOF should the NFL have the right to remove
    such players?

    I know this is a debate else way so I wanted to see what you all think.
    LT is just latest but there are others.
  2. Gwedd

    Gwedd Supporter Supporter

    #11 Jersey

    No. The HOF is supposed to represent the player's accomplishments on the field. If he's good enough to be selected, he's good enough to remain there.

    What he does afterward should have no bearing on his status once he's elected.

  3. JR4

    JR4 In the Starting Line-up Supporter

    So you don't mind that a player gets honored and seen by thousands of
    visitors a year even though he is a rapist. Suppose a mass killer?
    So a young boy visits the HOF and see player "XYZ" and wants to be like
    him. Some time later he finds out his idol is a mass killer or a rapist.
    That doesn't bother you?
  4. Gwedd

    Gwedd Supporter Supporter

    #11 Jersey

    Should "Time" magazine purge it's files of the issue where it named Hitler as "Man of the Year"?

    Heck, half the HoF statues would be removed if we judged them by their actions afterward. Where do you draw the line? Getting a DUI? Arrested for assault? Burglary? Spouse Abusive? Illegal Gambling?

    What if it was discovered that he had taken illegal drugs when he was a player, or steroids? Half the Steelers in the HoF would be tossed out, along with a LOT of players from the 70's and 80's.

    The HoF honors the player because of his accomplishments ON the field. If he messes up afterward, he'll likely have enough personal shunning by others to offset his status.
  5. JR4

    JR4 In the Starting Line-up Supporter

    I see your point and the line would be hard to draw. But there are some
    crimes that are just so bad that to honor such a person seems not right.
    Raping a 15 year old or a mass killing or murder incident for example.
    Such a player certainly deserves to be removed and not honored.

    Even when a player has retired, his character and what he does often
    reflects back to the NFL. Certainly true of NFL HOFers.
    Last edited: May 8, 2010
  6. Snake Eyes

    Snake Eyes Experienced Starter w/First Big Contract

    I grew up watching LT when I lived in NY and I worshipped him, when I read that he was arrested for rape it was like being punched in the stomach but even knowing what an utter disappointment he is as a person I still wouldnt want to have grown up without watching him.

    Being a great player doesn't mean one is a good person. I don't know what you think you'd be accomplishing by trying to shield kids from that fact, I'd rather them learn that lesson as soon as possible.
  7. JMarr

    JMarr In the Starting Line-Up

    Disagree. It should be about what the player accomplished while on the playing field, or representing the NFL in a significant capacity post-career, ala Pete Rose. What you're arguing for smacks of censorship. If anything, it's good for people to see guys like LT in the Hall of Fame--shows a) that anyone, now matter how much of a sports icon, can fall into the abyss post-career, and b) in LT's case, how someone who had known problems during his career wasn't able to ever exorcise his demons.
  8. JR4

    JR4 In the Starting Line-up Supporter

    It is sort of amazing to me that because a person is a great NFL player
    some think their personal responsibility of being a good citizen of the
    world doesn't matter.
    Let me ask you one question. Suppose player XYZ was nominated to be
    in the HOF as one of the greatest QBs ever and that player since retiring
    went berserk and killed his wife and two children for what ever reason.
    Do you think the committee would vote him into the NFL hall of fame?
  9. spacecrime

    spacecrime Veteran Starter w/Big Long Term Deal

    If it is a personal responsibility, it is personal and none of our business.

    Players are voted into the Hall of Fame by sports writers. It is risky enough to have them judge a players worth as an athlete.

    You are saying they should also judge the players on their morals.

    That is bad enough, but the possiblities for abuse are tremendous. Even if things could be done impartially and not on media hype and sensationalism it would never work have "being a good citizen of the world" more important than football prowess. Mother Teresa would be in the NFL HoF.

    But we all know that media sensationalism and hysteria would drive changes, just as sensationalism and hysteria are driving the creation of this thread.

    And, yes, LT is driving this thread. These threads ONLY appear when the media and fanatics are going beserk over the current scandal.

    Let's let the best football players in the world be Hall of Famers, and the best people in the world be saints. Mother Teresa may have been a good citizen of the world, but she shied away from tackles. Let's keep her out of the HoF and LT in.
  10. Deus Irae

    Deus Irae Retired Jersey Club Supporter

    Disable Jersey

    To me, Halls of Fame are about the person as a player. The off-the-field and post-career stuff is irrelevant, unless it's something that impacts game performance (PEDs, for example).
  11. JR4

    JR4 In the Starting Line-up Supporter

    Nice long response but you didn't answer my question.

    Suppose player XYZ was nominated to be
    in the HOF as one of the greatest QBs ever and that player since retiring
    went berserk and killed his wife and two children for what ever reason.
    Do you think the committee would vote him into the NFL hall of fame?

    Do not assume there is any directive by the NFL to consider off the field
    issues. Just a Yes or No would be fine.
  12. KontradictioN

    KontradictioN Do you even lift? Supporter

    No Jersey Selected

    This is basically what I wanted to say.
  13. Snake Eyes

    Snake Eyes Experienced Starter w/First Big Contract

    Why do you give a crap what the HoF committee thinks? They're a bunch of writers who have never played the game at the pro level, give me a committee made up of former players and coaches and I'll take what they think a lot more seriously.

    And yes, I would vote that QB to the HoF.
  14. ALP

    ALP Veteran Starter w/Big Long Term Deal

    as everyone else has said, HOF represents good football players

    its a shame these guys are not as good people as they were players, but what can one do?

    honor him for his football accomplishments, just like OJ, and he killed someone

    btw, at least to me, being in the HOF, means nothing when ur a killer or rapist, so its an empty "honor" as u call it
  15. MassPats38

    MassPats38 Supporter Supporter

    #87 Jersey

    I suspect many superstars are not the sort of person that the average person would want to spend time with given the effects of celebrity status and requirements to be successful in the game. Take away the game, and all that is left is that character.

    HOF status is for those who define the sport on the field, not off the field. It is a hard enough question to debate whether character matters to any great extent in making it to the HOF. There is no good character club, or records for being a solid citizen. You enter for the accomplishments while in the NFL, and no pictures or entries are added for what you later do, good or bad, after you are enshrined. If you can strip status for bad deeds, then how about adding guys like Byron White, who are credited with high accomplishments after their careers end? And how bad is a bad deed that would cause you to lose HOF status? Any post-enshrinement assessments are just too arbitrary.
  16. JR4

    JR4 In the Starting Line-up Supporter

    If character doesn't matter once you get into the HOF then why not apply
    the same logic to the active players of the NFL.
    Once you make a NFL roster character doesn't matter. But we do
    know it matters. If a player is bad enough he can get suspended

    Character matters going into the HOF, why shouldn't it matter once one
    is there? NFL heroes should be someone you can point a young man at
    and say ... see what he did ... you can be like him. I know it is not
    often possible but in extreme cases the NFL should step up and say
    this is not what we represent or condone and do something about it.
  17. JMarr

    JMarr In the Starting Line-Up

    Case by case basis, but in this case, the committee almost definitely would not. Me personally? Again I would not draw a bright line rule at all and might still vote yes depending on all the circumstances.

    Regardless, once he's been inducted, you don't 'de-induct' him and try to erase him from the memory books. That's like revisionist history,
  18. patsfan-1982

    patsfan-1982 In the Starting Line-Up

    no thats why i hate the baseball hall of fame cause they keeps guys like pete rose out the HOF is about what you did on the field not off of it.

    and as fas as our kids wanting to be like rapist and killers in the HOF i mean come on it's our job to raise our kids right not some football player that gets paid millions
  19. DaBruinz

    DaBruinz Pats, B's, Sox Supporter

    #50 Jersey

    The only time I have heard of someone being removed from a Hall of Fame is Alan Eagleson being removed from the Hockey Hall of Fame for numerous crimes committed as an agent and as the president of the NFLPA.

    The only other person I know of who has run afoul of a Hall of Fame is Pete Rose. Who was banned for betting on his own games while managing the Reds.. And he received a lifetime ban because it was directly related to the game.

    There are players whom I believe shouldn't have been elected because of what they did during their career.. That list includes Michael Irvin and Ray Lewis. But that's just me.
  20. mmasterkillah

    mmasterkillah On the Game Day Roster

    #11 Jersey

    If you take guys out because of off-field issues, than you ought to think about adding guys because they are good samaritans. Sound ridiculous? You betcha.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page