I have to agree Ryan....here's how I'd rank 'em
1. Phillip Rivers- he's done more with less then Eli and Big Ben.
2. Eli Manning- if his brother hadn't cast a huge shadow, we would all be praising this guy, he's gonna be good
3. Ben Roethlisberger- right now? he looks horrendous with a poor run game, however I expect the Steelers to draft a back (Bush?) soon, and then, he'll be back to normal, till then, his strong arm, and his leadership skills keep him here
4. Matt Leinart- already outshining Warner without 'Fitz, a line, or a run game
5. Alex Smith- his improvement after being thrown into the middle of a fiasco is impressive
6. Matt Schaub- He is cleary better then Vick, so why is Vick still starting? Because he wins games, I don't know if you can say the same about Schaub.
7. Bruce Gradkowski- how do you survive as a rookie QB in the league? it doesn't hurt to have some solid recievers, and a great run game.
8. Vince Young- so he can still run in the pros, the real question is can he make reads?