Rank your top 10 QB's in the league today.

[Patstopia]

I mean:

QB rating
2006: 101
2007: 98.0
2008: 95.0
2009: 99.9
2010: 91.9

TD%
2006: 5.6
2007: 6.0
2008: 4.9
2009: 5.8
2010: 4.9

INT%
2006: 1.6
2007: 2.7
2008: 2.2
2009: 2.8
2010: 2.5

Ahh, I see, you mean league wide

QB rating
2006: 101 1st
2007: 98.0 4th
2008: 95.0 5th
2009: 99.9 6th
2010: 91.9 10th

TD%
2006: 5.6 3rd
2007: 6.0 5th
2008: 4.9 6th
2009: 5.8 3rd
2010: 4.9

INT% Useless stat
2006: 1.6
2007: 2.7
2008: 2.2
2009: 2.8
2010: 2.5

PASSING YARDS
2010 2ND
2009 2ND
2008 6TH
2007 7TH
2006 2ND

 

[Deus Irae]

Ahh, I see, you mean league wide

QB rating
2006: 101 1st
2007: 98.0 4th
2008: 95.0 5th
2009: 99.9 6th
2010: 91.9 10th

TD%
2006: 5.6 3rd
2007: 6.0 5th
2008: 4.9 6th
2009: 5.8 3rd
2010: 4.9

INT% Useless stat
2006: 1.6
2007: 2.7
2008: 2.2
2009: 2.8
2010: 2.5

PASSING YARDS
2010 2ND
2009 2ND
2008 6TH
2007 7TH
2006 2ND

First, calling INT% a useless stat and then citing to passing yards as if it's meaningful was good comedy on your part.

Second, even when you play the "I'll convert the raw data to rankings" game, the downwards trend is there.

 

[BradyBranch39]

Brady
Rodgers
Eli
Brees
Peyton
Cutler
Stafford
Schaub
Roethlisberger
Ryan

Honorable mention #11 give him the surrounding cast of any of the guys above and he'd be there instead: Christian Ponder

 

[Texxx]

rodgers number 1 right now. to take brady over rodgers is complete homerism.

Absolutely not. Brady just had another record breaking season himself and went to his 5th SB. Look at the ridiculous weapons that Rodgers has to work with in comparison to Brady's weapons on offense. Huge advantage for Rodgers there. You could easily make a very strong argument that Brady is still the best QB in the league.

 

[Patstopia]

First, calling INT% a useless stat and then citing to passing yards as if it's meaningful was good comedy on your part.

Second, even when you play the "I'll convert the raw data to rankings" game, the downwards trend is there.

ok, int% leaders by year

2011 Alex Smith 1.1%
2010 Tom Brady 0.8%
2009 Brett Favre 1.3%
2008 Jason Campbell 1.2%
tied Seneca Wallace
2007 David Garrard 0.9%
2006 Damon Huard 0.4%

I guess I was wrong, it is a telling stat.

Anyway, I am done. Thanks for the entertainment. Is it August yet.

 

[Deus Irae]

ok, int% leaders by year

2011 Alex Smith 1.1%
2010 Tom Brady 0.8%
2009 Brett Favre 1.3%
2008 Jason Campbell 1.2%
tied Seneca Wallace
2007 David Garrard 0.9%
2006 Damon Huard 0.4%

I guess I was wrong, it is a telling stat.

Anyway, I am done. Thanks for the entertainment. Is it August yet.

You may be done but, since you pulled up names in a derogatory fashion, this needs a bit of followup:

2011 - Smith has best season to date, leads 49ers to NFCCG
2010 - Brady is NFL's first unanimous MVP
2009 - Favre Voted to Pro Bowl, leads Vikings to OT in NFCCG
2008 - Jason Campbell - the 2008 leader duo is the weakest of the bunch, but Campbell gets WAS to 8-8 under Zorn
2008 - Wallace guides a lousy Seattle team to 3 of its 4 wins on the season, going 3-5 while Hasselbeck went 1-6
2007 - Garrard leads Jags to playoffs, goes 9-3 as starter, wins playoff game
2006 - Huard only plays half the season, has QB rating of 98.0. Goes 5-3 as starter, helps Chiefs make playoffs

So, in other words, the examples you pulled for the stat you're bagging on indicate that the stat was a pretty good indicator for the time period you cited.

 

[goheels22002]

1. Eli Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Matthew Stafford
5. Ryan Fitzpatrick
6. Cam Newton
7. Drew Brees
8. Andrew Luck
9. Ben Roethlisberger
10. Robert Griffin III

Incomplete: Peyton Manning