as always, with Peyton, you have to ask if ur talking reg season alone, or are including post season
if ur including post season, Peyton was never anywhere near top 10, if ur only talking about reg season, there are qb's i would like to rate higher, such as rodgers and rivers, but its not easy to do so b/c those guys just cant get their teams to win as much, and thats really a QB's first job, win a game
peyton excels at that in the reg season, and therefore he still has a claim to the #2
but who cares about a ranking which doesn't include the postseason???