Read
There have already been books or accusations about Canseco, McGuire, Sosa, Palmeiro, Giambi, and Bonds. None of this is news; this new book doesn't push the debate in either direction. I think MLB has cause to exclude players if they broke rules and were caught doing that. But MLB didn't have a steroids policy before 2002. Bottom line - they either all have to go down or all get a pass, even if it sucks to do it.
I think it's dumb, but I think it's more unfair to screw over a few players who technically didn't violate rules. I mean, what about the players that didn't get caught? For example, not to say in any way that they did, but what if Albert Pujols or A-Rod used steroids at some point? What if Roger Clemens used steroids to extend his career?
Here is an excerpt I found on Hall of Fame pitchers like Gaylord Perry who greased, spit, and scuffed their balls and don't even think they did anything wrong:
http://espn.go.com/mlb/columns/bp/1383204.html
"Parrish was right; pitchers cheating has been a part of baseball as long as the game has been played. Some of the greatest pitchers in baseball were cheaters, caught and admitted. Joe Niekro, Whitey Ford -- who once said, "It was as though I had my own tool bench out there with me," -- and even Don Sutton, who when accused of using foreign substances, is said to have replied, "Not true at all. Vaseline is manufactured right here in the United States."
Without any doubt, though, the greatest cheater of all was Gaylord Perry.
Perry spent two years bouncing between the minors and the Giants before he started cheating. He then carved out a 22-year career that put him in Cooperstown. Perry wasn't only a great cheater, though, he was a great pitcher with enormous talent: he won two Cy Young Awards, becoming the first pitcher to receive the honor in both leagues, finished in the top 10 in ERA 11 times and strikeouts 12 times, and went to the All-Star Game five times. He was a better-than average pitcher as late as 1980, when he was 40 and had been pitching for 18 seasons.
Though he's known as a spitball artist, Gaylord Perry didn't throw a spitter when he cheated, for the most part. He threw greaseballs. Vaseline was his mainstay, but as a great cheating mind, Perry was open to experimentation. "Man, I tried everything," Perry once said. "When my wife was having babies the doctor would send over all kinds of stuff and I'd try that, too. Once I even used fishing line oil."
.