Reid was just extended by the Eagles for 3 years. I wanted to know what people here think of him as a coach. Some Reid facts: He has the exact win% in the reg season as BB. Andy Reid - 105 wins - 66 losses - 1 tie - .614% win% Bill Belichick - 145 wins - 91 losses - 0 ties - .614% win% Now BB has had more success in the Playoffs (goes w/o saying) but Reid still has taken his team to the playoffs 7 times out of 10 yrs in Philly and he is in position to do it again this year. He took the Eagles to the NFC championship game 5 times in 8 years (01, 02, 03, 04 and 08). Now they only made the SB in 2004 (losing to the PATS) but still he is a 'winner'. With all that said I think he is overrated becasue his team losses at least 1-2 games a year they should not and I believe 'good' coaches don't let that happen. Now BB's Pats are doing the same thing with losses this year to teams they should beat. Does this change my opinion of Reid. Maybe a little. If BB retired today and you could have Reid as the next NE coach would you want him?