Name the top 10 players in SBXLVI

[patsinthesnow]

Just curious what you guys think are the top 10 players in SB46, as I hear many giants fans and the media saying they have better players than the Patriots. What is your opinion?

1. Tom Brady
2. Eli Manning
3. Rob Gronkowski
4. Vince Wilfork
5. Wes Welker
6. Jason Pierre-Paul
7. Hakeem Nicks
8. Victor Cruz
9. Jerod Mayo
10. Justin Tuck

 

[JackBauer]

You could argue #10, but that looks more or less correct.

 

[patsfaninpa]

1. Tom Brady
2. Eli Manning
3. Wes Welker
4. Jason Pierre-Paul
5. Vince Wilfork
6. Justin Tuck
7. Hakeem Nicks
8. Victor Cruz
9. Rob Gronkowski - Downgraded because of injury. I'd put him at 3 if healthy.
10. Matt Light - Best OL on either team this year.

My next 3-4 might be all Pats; Mayo, Mankins and Hernandez. Then Osi.

 

[PATRIOTSFANINPA]

Tom Brady
Rob Gronkowski (at 100%)
Eli Manning
Wes Welker
Osi Umenyiora
Victor Cruz
Vince Wilfork
Brian Waters
Matt Light
Justin Tuck

 

[Funktopus]

Snee was a probowl alternate.

 

[wistahpatsfan]

1. Brady
2. Gronkowski
3. Wilfork
4. Welker
5. Mankins
6. Hernandez
7. Light
8. Mayo
9. Waters
10. Gostowski

Had enough of the whole "Giants are as good as us" crap.
They're not.

Signed,
Wistapatsfan

 

[TriplecHamp]

1)TFB
2) Elisha
3) Gronk
4) Wilfork
5) JPP
6) Welker
7) Cruz
8) Hakeem
9) Hernandez
10) Light/Walters/Tuck

 

[patsfaninpa]

Snee was a probowl alternate.

Mankins was a starter. And, so was Brian Waters. Your point?

 

[Patsfan1102]

1.Brady
2.Wilfork
3.Eli
4.Gronk
5.Welker
6.Cruz
7.Mayo
8.JPP
9.Tuck
10.Nicks

 

[Gronkandez]

1.Brady
2.Gronk
3.Eli
4.Wilfolk
5. JPP
5.Welker
6.Tuck
7.Nicks
8. Hernandez
9. Light
10.Osi

 

[Funktopus]

Mankins was a starter. And, so was Brian Waters. Your point?

I thought he might be left out of the discussion. I'm glad you mentioned Waters.

 

[JackBauer]

Tom Brady
Rob Gronkowski (at 100%)
Eli Manning
Wes Welker
Osi Umenyiora
Victor Cruz
Vince Wilfork
Brian Waters
Matt Light
Justin Tuck

How does Hakeem Nicks not make this list? Or JPP?

 

[BradyBranch39]

I'm with you on the top 8, perhaps in that order.

Get down to 81-90 would be more interesting, because Ocho could be #85.

 

[MNF]

1. Brady
2. Gronkowski
3. Wilfork
4. Welker
5. Mankins
6. Hernandez
7. Light
8. Mayo
9. Waters
10. Gostowski

Had enough of the whole "Giants are as good as us" crap.
They're not.

Signed,
Wistapatsfan

Love it!

10 chars

 

[mderderi]

Brady
Gronk
Manning
Wilfork
Pierre-Paul
Welker
Tuck
Nicks
Osi
Cruz

 

[jsull87]

most important? more about Matchups than players for me. Who ever wins these wins.

1. Brady
2. Eli
3. Light/JPP
4.Tuck/Mankins
5. Osi/Solder
6. Welker/Webster
7. Devin/Nicks
8. Cruz/Arrington
9. Wilfork/Snee
10. Chung (pass)/ Spikes/Mayo (run)

 

[sly24]

Brady
Manning
Gronkowski
Osi
JPP
Wilfork
Nicks
Cruz
Mankins
Welker

 

[Ring 6]

Just curious what you guys think are the top 10 players in SB46, as I hear many giants fans and the media saying they have better players than the Patriots. What is your opinion?

1. Tom Brady
2. Eli Manning
3. Rob Gronkowski
4. Vince Wilfork
5. Wes Welker
6. Jason Pierre-Paul
7. Hakeem Nicks
8. Victor Cruz
9. Jerod Mayo
10. Justin Tuck

There are a lot of guys on that list that arent likely the best player in the NFL at thier position, like Logan Mankins.

 

[Ring 6]

This thread has proven one thing. Justin Tuck is clearly the most overrated player.

 

[TheComeback]

This thread has proven one thing. Justin Tuck is clearly the most overrated player.

He's inconsistent, but I wouldn't say overrated. When he's on, he's just as good as Pierre-Paul.