From 2005-2011 which appears to be the timeframe in question the Patriot offense is
1st in scoring
2nd in passing yards
1st in TD passes
1st in QB rating
1st in fewest Ints
3rd in % completed
Its is ridiculous to say that the draft picks on WRs over this period of time has hurt the passing game or franchise.
I think on messageboards it always ends up with people arguing these extreme viewpoints, when it's rarely the case that things are so black and white.
what you say is true, that bottom line results matter, and I wouldn't say drafting some dud wr has been first on a list of issues, but that doesn't mean it can't be on the list.
those stats you post up are regular season stats, and I think we'd probably all be in agreement that at this point the fans and players set the bar a little higher than regular season success.
to use specific examples, while it's unquestionably a total team game, one problem we had that contributed to the '06 loss is lack of a guy like welker who could hold onto a ball.
we couldn't keep a drive alive in the second half, and that was a big factor.
replace caldwell with a welker and we win that game, and the superbowl, imo.
if you want to look at the 2 giants superbowls, neither game was up to our expected offensive output, and a few extra points might mean 2 more superbowls.
when the guy goes through a list and looks at each case I think they can be evaluated (in hindsight) without any macro analysis of 6 years worth or regular season stats, and that's not even including the players at other positions we might have used those picks on instead.
but everybody here would have plenty of busts on their mock drafts, as well as the real drafts of the rest of the nfl.