Manning's rep cemented??

Discussion in ' - Patriots Fan Forum' started by onegameatatime, Jan 17, 2006.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. onegameatatime

    onegameatatime Third String But Playing on Special Teams

    People look to the John Elway example -- couldn't win the SB until late in his career, but did Elway lose a SB where Denver was favored? (maybe against Washington)

    Manning apologists have come up with ever excuse, but what is it going to be this year. Colts had:

    #1 seed
    playing #6 seed
    in a dome
    against a non-dome team
    favorable defensive rules on illegal contact
    Manning has 3 pro bowl players on offense
    3 pro bowl players on defense
    No significant starter in IR!!!
    No significant players missing for the game (?)
    The benefit of two really bad calls (the no-interference and the no-interception)

    And then in and after the game:

    weak offense
    bad on-field decision-making at the end trying to be a big hero rather moving the team down with the time outs to better position
    throwing his O-line under the bus after the game
  2. oldrover

    oldrover 2nd Team Getting Their First Start

    #50 Jersey

    You forgot 'having his daddy make excuses for him'.
  3. SamBam39

    SamBam39 Third String But Playing on Special Teams

    moron sissy boy's rep was cemented log ago.

    when he speaks, I hear the theme from 'deliverance'.

    there could not be a human with less dignity.
  4. coltshater

    coltshater Practice Squad Player

    Where's Tony Collins when you need him? He must defend Manning & the Colts honor!

    I give it 30 minutes. :D
  5. Murphys95

    Murphys95 Third String But Playing on Special Teams

    I root against Manning as hard as the next guy, but he may only be half way through his career. I'm with ya, it's fun to root against him - just like it was fun to root against Marino. But I cheer against him because he's good, darn good!

    It's too early to judge. And even if Peyton should end his career without a championship, he'll still go down as one of the greatest.
  6. Willie55

    Willie55 In the Starting Line-Up

    I cheer against Goober because he always has an excuse, it's never his fault. Plus he's part of the Colts organization who has Polian, another person who always has excuses.

    MDPATSFAN On the Game Day Roster

    He gets happy feet come play off time.
  8. mtbykr

    mtbykr Supporter Supporter

    #37 Jersey


    There is one major difference between PM, Elway, and Marino: Marino and Elway actually went to a Superbowl early in their career-------PM has yet to even make an appearence!
  9. sarge

    sarge Rotational Player and Threatening Starter's Job

    A better question is did Elway ever lose a SB where he had a running game.

    Elway never did it till he got a running game.

    Manning has had that his entire career!

    Manning is surrounded by far more talent on offense then Elway was as well!
  10. marty

    marty In the Starting Line-Up

    Well if his rep isn't his feet certainly should be!!! :bricks:
  11. FSUPatsFan

    FSUPatsFan Third String But Playing on Special Teams

    I know most people probably heard this, but for those who haven't, Peyton Mannings next playoff start will make him the QB with the most playoff starts before reaching the superbowl. I guess there is one major difference between PM and every other QB to ever play the game.
  12. Na_polian

    Na_polian On the Game Day Roster

    Fixed it :p
  13. maverick4

    maverick4 Banned


    Peyton Manning, when all is said and done, will not be among the all-time top 5 quarterback lists.

    Please don't compare him to John Elway or Dan Marino. John Elway took the Broncos to the Superbowl 5 times. The first three times they were destroyed, but the Broncos had no business even being there in some of those years if it weren't for Elway.

    Marino went to the Superbowl in his second season, and after that played on teams that were nowhere as good as Peyton's.

    Peyton Manning has a history of choking going back to his high school days.

    Why do Colts fans refuse to acknowledge this?

  14. onegameatatime

    onegameatatime Third String But Playing on Special Teams

    I believe the guys from CHFF would disagree with you on Marino. I remember an analysis showing rather convincingly a long record of underachievement in the playoffs.
  15. PromisedLand

    PromisedLand Virtual Internet Person

    Much as I dislike the guy, I have to say, "no, his reputation is not cemented." He will always have the possibility of redeeming it until his playing days are over.
  16. PATSNUTme

    PATSNUTme Paranoid Homer Moderator Staff Member Supporter

    #75 Jersey

    I'll bet that the media will be back to gushing over him next year.
  17. BradyisGod

    BradyisGod Rotational Player and Threatening Starter's Job

    You may be right, but there is something about this time that seems different. It's like the media has finally realized what a choker he is. And what a whiny pain in the *** he is as well.
  18. dante828

    dante828 On the Roster

    I don't know, whether its Dr. Z or PTI, people are starting to change there tunes back to defending Manning, especially since he has gotten so much criticism over the weekend (all deserved by the way). It's like people started to realize they may have gone too far in their criticisms (I don't think they have gone far enough). Manning is like Favre at this point, the media may point out one or two bad things but the media will not turn on them completely. I am not sure why they refuse to go after Manning, I mean, has anyone looked so disgusted with there team so consistently as Manning? Has anyone so completely emasculated his coach during a game? Has anyone thrown their own teammates under the bus after a huge playoff loss? Has anyone ever come up so short considering his potential? Yet he'll remain the NFL's dandy as long as he throws 3 touchdowns a game against the Cardinals and Browns of the league. Peter King said yesterday that he would bet anyone that Manning would win 2 Super Bowls over the next nine years. I would take that bet in a second.
  19. Bostonian1962

    Bostonian1962 In the Starting Line-Up

    I heard it explained that with guys like Brady and Elway, the game slows down for them in the playoffs. With Manning in pressure games, the game speeds up drastically.

    It's interesting to hear others now say Manning isn't money. We've been saying that for years.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page