Manning not in Brady's league

Discussion in ' - Patriots Fan Forum' started by ManningOverratedHick, Jan 13, 2008.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Go back to doing more commercials.
    Last edited by a moderator: Jan 13, 2008
  2. TheGodInAGreyHoodie

    TheGodInAGreyHoodie Experienced Starter w/First Big Contract

    I dunno he seemed pretty impressive out there today:

    12 for 18, 163 yards 2 TDs no int, no fumbles. Manning is solid, I would not be surprised if he lead his team to the SB.
  3. Ootball

    Ootball Guest

    It does Brady no good that so many of his fans seem so intent on disparaging & diminishing one of the outstanding QB's who he is playing in his era.

    If Manning sucks, and - as the current SB champion - is a real choker, then ol' Tom didn't have to do too much to distinguish himself during these years, did he?

    Brady is cool, and the Pats players all seem like decent fellows (well, everyone but Harrison); it's too bad the fans have to act the way they do.
  4. BradyFTW

    BradyFTW Rookie

    "it's too bad the fans have to act the way they do" - you mean like trolling another teams board to tell them they act bad?
    :bricks: :eek: :bricks:
  5. kriskanos

    kriskanos On the Game Day Roster

    Manning is a small game QB but otherwise he has all the skills. Its just his peanut shaped head cant take the pressure.
  6. PatsFaninAZ

    PatsFaninAZ In the Starting Line-Up

    Good point. Not in Brady's league, but solid.

    He also got his second playoff win much quicker than his big brother ever did. (His big brother also plays football professionally, fyi.)
  7. bolts_fan

    bolts_fan Practice Squad Player

    There's NEVER anything wrong with calling an idiot, an idiot.
  8. CapePatsFan

    CapePatsFan Rookie

    Actually, he played really well.... but, did anyone catch him when he was on the sidelines? He looked like a zombie, just sitting there and staring. Contrast that w/ Brady who is either locked in convo. w/ McDaniels, talking w/ his receivers, or generally just pumping up and connecting w/ his team. The intangible little things like that make a difference in the playoffs.
  9. TommyD4207

    TommyD4207 On the Game Day Roster

    He played well until the end of the game when they needed him most.

    1-7 0 TD 1 INT
  10. FreakGoDeep

    FreakGoDeep Practice Squad Player

    After seeing the colts-chargers i said to myself that manning is atleast 2 levels under brady.
    You gonna tell me that a guy who is 7-7 in the playoffs can be considered on the same level as a guy who is 13-2 and just went 16-0.

    Brady is just about the greatest QB ever and by the time he is done he'll be standing alone at the top.

    Enjoy it because we are seeing one of the greatest athletes in the history of sports doing it better than anyone else.
  11. fnordcircle

    fnordcircle brady plz Supporter

    This thread is retarded. If Brady was wearing blue and white and Manning blue and silver you'd be saying the exact opposite.

    Peyton Manning is either the best or second best QB in the league and a top 5 all time QB. His accomplishments in no way diminish what Brady has done and while for my money Brady is the QB I'd most want to have here there is nothing wrong with acknowledging, however begrudgingly, how great Manning has become. There is no way you can say he choked today.

    I honestly do not know why some of you seem so antagonized by Manning. It's immature.
  12. SeymourTrophies

    SeymourTrophies Rotational Player and Threatening Starter's Job

    #93 Jersey

    That message didn't strike me as a troll message. This is the first message I've read from him, but it was pretty on target. A little humility never hurts.

    Manning is not a bad quarterback, classless, or any other negative implication that has been made. He just doesn't always do what it takes to win or prepare himself in the necessary fashion. Point some of the blame at Dungy who facilitated a lax approach every time the Colts have laid an egg.
  13. Fencer

    Fencer Veteran Starter w/Big Long Term Deal

    #12 Jersey

  14. jcdavey

    jcdavey In the Starting Line-Up

  15. Haterproof

    Haterproof Third String But Playing on Special Teams

    I'm pretty sure any NFL fan with real football knowledge knows that Brady & Manning are the 2 best QB'S in the league.I rank Brady at #1 & Manning at #2.The 1 thing Brady does particuly better than Manning is playing under pressure.Brady is his best in big games.Just my 2 cents.
  16. jbb9s

    jbb9s In the Starting Line-Up

    Brady has engineered the greatest playoff run ever in 04 when he beat clearly the 2nd, 3rd and 4th best teams in the league (Colts, Steelers, Eagles). No one has ever really done that.
  17. PatriotsReign

    PatriotsReign Hall of Fame Poster

    #18 Jersey

    He is great, but if he was our QB and Brady was theirs, no way we'd have 3 SB can take that to the bank.
  18. PatriotsReign

    PatriotsReign Hall of Fame Poster

    #18 Jersey

    jcdavey, I recognize your name from the days I used to visit

    Welcome and I look forward to reading some of your posts in the coming week.
  19. Ootball

    Ootball Guest

    Interesting take. I'm not being cute here, but do you think Indy would have 3 if the QB's had been switched at the start?
  20. CapePatsFan

    CapePatsFan Rookie

    Sort of see your point, but no, it's not retarded. If Manning were the Pats qb I really doubt we'd be undefeated. Manning is great, no doubt...but time after time he just reminds me of a better version of Drew Bledsoe, complete w/ jumpy happy feet, and always somehow seeming to come up short when it counts. No choking?? That last series??
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page