huskeralk said:
Then Brady could retire after this season and get in too. I was surprised Aikman got in this fast. Lets compare stats here.
Aikman:
TOTAL 165 4715 2898 61.5 32942 7.0 165 TD 141 ints.
Brady:
TOTAL 78 2548 1577 61.9 18035 7.08 123 TD 66 ints.
Two more seasons and Brady will have easily eclipsed Aikman's TD total. Not to mention the fact that Brady has already won as man Super Bowl's as Aikman has.
Yeah but your assuming that induction to the hall is based on intelligence and logic. It's not. It's as much a popularity vote as the Pro Bowls are and therefore, just as flawed.
It's interesting how lasting first impressions can be.
Aikman was always loved by the media machine. They painted him as the blond haired, blue eyed all american quarterback of "America's Team".
Brady on the other hand, hasn't been "given" anything. Throughout his career they've tried to minimize and belittle his accomplishments. They labeled him a "6th round pick" and a "system quarterback" and no matter what he accomplishes in New England, somewhere in the back of the collective minds of the machine, Brady will always carry that (mis)label.
It's irony at it's worst.
Aikman actually fits the definition of "system quarterback" to a tee. Aikman's numbers are quite mediocre. The real evidence though is how the team never missed a beat when he missed time. Buerleine, Kosar, Garett...They all had success QB'ing that team. But when Aikman was healthy and his supporting case was out, the Cowboys always struggled miserably on offense. Take away Emmit, Irvin, or even Novacek and Aikman couldn't do anything with that offense. He needed every single one of his playmakers.
The best thing about Aikman is how he did elevate his game in the postseason.
But a FIRST BALLOT Hall of Famer??????????
And what about Warren Moon? I don't really have a problem with either getting in but neither was good enough to go in on their first chance.
This isn't the Hall of the very good. It's the Hall of Fame.
If Warren Moon is a first ballot Hall of Famer then so should Andre Tippet be. Tippet was better compared to his peers than Moon was to his. Until he got injured, Tippet was no worse than the 2nd best OLB in the game. When was Moon every rated amongst the top 2 at his position or even the top 5 for that matter.
Same thing with Jim Kelly.
What's next? Dave Krieg? Boomer Esiason?