Discussion in 'PatsFans.com - Patriots Fan Forum' started by PatsFan24, Mar 17, 2008.
i know the free agency is slow but this question is really digging deep
ive been on this board for awhile and the threads this year are the worst ive ever seen.
All depends, would he have the same staff that Brady did for that year?
I vote you off the island.
I know the definitive answer, but I'm keeping it to myself.
If he played for the Pats, I believe Peyton would've at least won one for the fact that he actually had a good defense and Belichick as coach. he definitely wouldn't have won 3, but I'd have to give him one of the Super Bowls.
he is from North Dakota though, you know how those people are
Thread of the Year!
Floppityjillion. Or zero.
You know, whichever.
Ok..then if you are going to ask this, then how many would Tom Brady have won with the Colts...?
I doubt 3 ...
No one on this board takes this poll seriously, I promise you. Both are all-time greats, and the fact that people are still starting these threads is a sad commentary on how little some people appreciate the chance to see two amazing players in their prime compete every year.
I think the whole point is moot and was just saying heck you could ask about ANY player.
Peyton would not have won any Super Bowls as a Patriot. Why? Because he would have bought a fancy convertible as a rookie and then fatally hit his massive forehead on the Storrow Drive underpass going 70 mph.
Not exactly true. If you asked, "How many Super Bowls would the Pats have won if Chad Pennington was the QB?" then the answer is a resounding zero.
If you don't mind a Colts fan chiming in I think he would have at least 2 for the simple reason of BB is a much better coach with a killer instinct to win games. On the flip side I wonder how Brady would fair on the Colts, maybe 1 SB win? not a knock on Brady in any way shape or form but more of a knock on the Indy coaches. Just my two cents
None - Manning wouldn't fit in!
Same as that I doubt Brady would fit into the Colts system!!
would Manning be able to do what Brady has done (except this season) with average recievers??
He had Harrison and Wayne for a 'few' years - Brady had average for a 'few' years!
he's got a thousand posts, so let's give him one stinker...but he's on double secret probation!!!!
Separate names with a comma.