Welcome to PatsFans.com

Freedom Of Speech ???

Discussion in 'Political Discussion' started by Turk, Sep 27, 2007.

  1. Turk

    Turk Rookie

    Joined:
    Oct 31, 2004
    Messages:
    1,072
    Likes Received:
    3
    Ratings:
    +3 / 0 / -0

    Being Heard On Campus
    September 25, 2007
    By Tulin Daloglu
    Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's speech at Columbia University made me
    think about freedom of speech on America's college campuses.

    Mr. Ahmadinejad - who represents a country the State Department calls a state
    sponsor of terror, who represents a country that helps Iraqi militias, kill
    American troops and who denies the Holocaust and calls for Israel's destruction
    - was allowed to speak at one of America's most prestigious campuses. But
    Archbishop Mesrob II Mutafyan, the Armenian patriarch of Istanbul, was denied
    the same privilege last week at Georgetown University's Woodstock Theological
    Center.

    When the archbishop first visited the United States in April, he spoke at
    Southern Methodist University, and said something Armenian-Americans never
    question. Last Thursday, Harut Sassounian, the publisher of the California
    Courier, a weekly English-language Armenian newspaper based in Los Angeles,
    explained that Mr. Mutafyan had challenged the notion that Armenians were
    innocent victims of the Ottomans during its last days. "Did some Armenian
    political parties promote armed rebellion in the Armenian community?" the
    archbishop asked in his April speech. "They did. In some areas, did armed
    Armenian gangs work together with the Russian army? They did. But the government
    of the Committee for Union and Progress, being in charge of the country, is
    chiefly responsible for the painful events that occurred and the great suffering
    that was endured." He charged both Armenians and Turks with making peace with
    their past and acknowledged that Armenians must also clarify their history.

    Mr. Mutafyan is voicing an unheard split within the Armenian community as
    support grows in the House for congressional legislation recognizing the
    Armenian genocide. If he could have spoken at Georgetown, he would have been
    able to say that "we have to change the mentality shown by some Armenian
    historians who still see the Turks as uncultured barbarian emigrants from
    Central Asia." But the Armenian American lobby is determined to keep that
    perception of Turkey in the United States.

    The Armenian National Committee of America quoted Rep. Adam Schiff, California
    Democrat, the lead sponsor of the House Armenian Genocide Resolution, as saying,
    "In order to perpetuate its campaign of denial, Turkey seeks to intimidate all
    Armenians worldwide, but especially the Armenians in Turkey who must live with
    daily threats." Mr. Schiff said that "the editor of the... Armenian language
    newspaper in Turkey, Hrant Dink, was assassinated for writing about the genocide (my notes here - Dink was very critical of the word "genocide", he promoted research and healing for all victims)
    this year, and a popular video now being circulated in Turkey celebrates his
    killers and threatens Armenians." Mr. Schiff did not acknowledge that the
    assassination of Mr. Dink, a beloved Armenian-Turkish journalist, was a crime -
    and has been treated as such. And while that disturbing video exists, there is
    another, a much more popular video, which calls for unity and shows the protests
    by thousands of Turks against Mr. Dink's murder.

    Mr. Schiff can cherry-pick examples to criticize Turks and Turkey, but he
    neither shows the whole picture nor acknowledges the society's true nature and
    values. Mr. Mutafyan, however, admits that there is much unity in the gray
    areas. Nearly 40,000 Armenians work in Turkey illegally; surely they would not
    if they felt they were in constant peril. "trategists sin by...turning the youth
    of the two countries against each other," he has said.

    The Armenian National Committee of America, in a letter circulated last week to
    members of Congress, said that "Patriarch Mutafyan... lives in constant fear of
    acts of discrimination and retribution by a Turkish government that actively
    persecutes those who speak freely" in recognizing genocide claims. So it blocked
    his speech. Mr. Mutafyan's "political statements are made under Turkish pressure
    and do not reflect his true views on the Armenian genocide," says Sassounian.
    However, when I interviewed the archbishop, he said, "It is all lie. I am here
    with my own free will." But he was sad. "I learned that the speech is cancelled
    due to threats to my security... America should have been the country of
    freedom, but things do happen here, too," he said.

    There is an admirable elegance in the way the Armenian-Americans promote freedom
    of speech in Turkey, but one has to wonder whether they really believe in total
    freedom of speech. Is it so outrageous to think that the Armenian patriarch of
    Istanbul would sincerely call upon all parties - Turks, Armenians and others -
    to consider looking for "new primary sources?" What if he really believes that
    both sides will heal by strengthening today's relationships and assuring
    tomorrow's friendships? What if he believes that the House resolution will only
    please the Armenian diaspora?

    Finally, Turkey is no Iran. It is a NATO ally and has started full membership
    accession talks with the European Union. If the archbishop could have spoken, he
    would have suggested constructive solutions to bring people together. What's
    more, American colleges and universities derive their strength from their
    students' ability to think critically and ask questions. If Mr. Mutafyan were
    not to speak his own mind, they would have easily discredited him.

    Last but not the least, if Mr. Ahmadinejad can speak at Columbia, certainly
    Mesrub II Mutafyan, the Armenian Patriarch of Istanbul, deserves a chance to be
    heard.

    Tulin Daloglu is a freelance writer.
    Last edited: Sep 27, 2007
  2. Harry Boy

    Harry Boy Look Up, It's Amazing PatsFans.com Supporter

    Joined:
    Nov 10, 2005
    Messages:
    40,194
    Likes Received:
    196
    Ratings:
    +666 / 2 / -9

    They let the minutemen speak also, then they tried to kill them.
    :bricks:

Share This Page

unset ($sidebar_block_show); ?>