DW Toys
In the Starting Line-Up
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2007
- Messages
- 4,439
- Reaction score
- 1,881
Tamme is strictly pass-catcher. He's actually more H-back than true tight end.
And Jamie Silva would make this team measurably worse. He's not fast, not quick, not agile, and doesn't appear to be that disciplined either. Really, is there any DB on this team he'd be an improvement on? Including Ventrone? He'll probably have a Ventrone/Shawn Mayer career. Special Teams player. (Not that that's a bad thing. If the Patriots won the SB, Ventone's awesome tackle on the last kickoff return would have been an important play.)
Cousin,
I appreciate your input and are well versed in your discussions. I respect your opinion but I think that Tamme was more than a catching TE at UK as they had a substantial run game. He is bigger than Thomas and we all hope, more physically tolerant of the game. Is anybody that reads this satisfied with Ben Watson? With Moss and Welker he should have had 60 catches as at least an outlet. Then he has his usual mid-season vacation for a few games. He is just not tough, nor does he posses hands. How many of you gasp when TB throws his way? His 4.45 speed does not translate on the field other than the Bailey play. His blocking has gotten better this year until the SB. He was awful in that game!
I think Tamme would bulk some for the NFL. It's my opinion, but see how big Witten was when he was drafted by the Cowboys. Pretty good TE these days. Would you swap Witten for Watson?
Nobody has addressed this, but S is as much of (almost) a need as CB. Why has nobody called that out? We have one youngster who could be decent but is developing slower than we had all hoped in "Metal Mitts Merriweather". We have a possible future HOF S in Harrison and then who? Nobody! "Smoking Willie"? But Harrison needs to be rotated next year to keep him fresh and maybe off the field in deep pass situations. He has digressed in coverage.
Sanders? Young man please....! Sanders misses the whole point of this game. You need to tackle and cover as a safety.
Now about Silva. He's bigger than Sanders. He's faster than Sanders (4.6 vs 4.67) he had 6 interceptions this year even after missing a game or two. He hits and covers better right now than Sanders and he can return punts (not bad either mind you for a "slow guy"). Yes I agree he is all over the field, If you saw the EW Shrine game, he was one of the better players on the field with many tackles. You could be right in comparisons but as a fifth or sixth rounder, this kid makes the squad I think. Plus he is tough unlike our present #36.
We need a S! O.K. How about Hamlin the FA. I think 5 INT's and not bad in coverage or tackling. He is like 28 as well. Now I have been blasted for saying Ed Reed but he is gonna be thirty (young for BB) and they have two other safeties (one was on IR) who aren't bad. Ogden is gone so they need a OT big time. Kaczur is young and the Ravens then get two choices in the top ten to build around and we drop down to round two for better value.
This is all fun to speculate and as said, I respect your ideas.
DW Toys