Re: 2010 Draft Prospects.
Nice work. Some comments on individual positional rankings:
I'd rather have a power back than an all-purpose back. Best, Spiller and Devine are fine players, but I don't think we need that kind of player as much as a power back to complement Maroney, with Morris and Taylor aging and injury prone. I see Brandon Tate becoming our all-purpose guy. Of Best and Spiller I prefer Best, but I just don't see spending that high a pick on that kind of player (a late round pick, yes - I wanted Devin Moore of Wyomin, but that was pre-Tate).
I rank Mathews slightly ahead of Dwyer right now, based on his ability to do more things (including block and receive) and his home run capability. But I like both guys a lot.
I'm not impressed with Evan Royster. I'd rather have Gerhart or Dixon as a mid-round prospect.
I think Graham and Romeus are more 4-3 DEs than 3-4 OLBs. I'm not sure either has the ability to play in space. I like both, but not for the Pats.
I divide this position into primary DE guys who can play the elephant, and guys who are 3-4 OLBs who could also play SAM:
- The former group includes Morgan, Hardy and Griffen. I would also put Jason Pierre-Paul and Carlos Dunlap in the same group. Romeus might qualify, but I think he's too stiff to play in space. Of the 5 guys I've listed, I think all 5 would be dynamic playmakers for the Pats.
- The second group includes Sapp, Hughes, Kindle and Norwood. I prefer Kindle and Hughes for the Pats. I don't think Sapp is strong enough at the edge and against the run. I love Norwood, but I see him more as an SILB for us because of his lack of height (6'1") which would limit him at OLB. He could certainly play SAM for us, and 3-4 OLB in a pinch. I think Von Miller is a pure rush OLB and doesn't do enough of the other things which BB demands in his OLBs. Nice rusher, though. The guy I may like most of all is junior Jeremy Beal of Oklahoma (6'3" 257#), who is sort of a hybrid between Hughes and Kindle, and who originally came to OU as a linebacker. He's flying under the rader, but I think he's a big time player.
As mentioned above, I consider Eric Norwood more of an SILB than a 3-4 OLB prospect for the Pats. I rank him behind Ronald McClain and ahead of Brandon Spikes.
Sean Weatherspoon is a great player, but I don't see him being stout enough to play ILB for the Pats. Maybe WILB, but Mayo and Guyton already do a lot of the things which Weatherspoon does.
Herzlich was great last year, but he has major health issues, and I don't think he'll be coming out this year.
I don't like any of the other guys you listed for the Pats at ILB. They're all too slight and not strong enough at the point.
Two guys who I do like, after the elite top 3: Chris Galippo of USC (6'2" 255# red shirt sophomore) and Pat Angerer of Iowa. Angerer is only 235# but plays very tough, and if he could bulk up 10-15 lbs. he would be solid.
Suh is the obvious #1 3-4 DE prospect. I'm not sure McCoy is a great 3-4 DE candidate, though. He's much more of a penetrating UT. I also see Brian Price as more of a pure 3-4 DE.
I don't see Carlos Dunlap as a 3-4 DE. It's just not his game at all. I also don't think he's 290 lbs., more like 270. I see him more as a 4-3 DE/elephant prospect than a 3-4 DE.
Cameron Heyward and Corey Wooton are both extremelyintriguing. The sky is the limit for both. Wooton is just beginning to regain his 2008 pre-injury form. Heyward would be a stud. He may have the highest upside of any 3-4 DE prospect. He's everything that Dunlap is not as a 3-4 DE prospect.
Arthur Jones is definitely one of the better 3-4 DE prospects. I also think Jared Odrick of Penn State is a solid 3-4 DE. Marvin Austin and Allen Bailey are also solid 3-4 DE prospects.
Two guys not on your list who I really like are Florida junior Lawrence Marsh (6'5" 305# and very athletic) and Iowa junior Adrian Clayborn (6'3" 282#). I think Marsh is very much in the Seymour mold as an athletic 3-4 DE. He's flying under the radar right now and could be a steal. Clayborn is a tad undersized right now, but just makes plays.
I love Iupati, as I've mentioned previously. Of the Pouncey twins, I think that Maurkice Pouncey is much more talented than Mike; he also has the versatility to play both center and guard, which BB would appreciate. Those are my top 2 guys. I also think Wisconsin RT Gabe Carmini could probably play a vicious RG for us.
You left out OT prospects. Look forward to seeing your rankings there.
Again, great job.
Thanks for the input.
Here are the rest:
OT:
1. Russell Okung - Oklahoma State
2. Bryan Bulaga - Iowa
3. Trent Williams - Oklahoma
4. Charles Brown - USC
5. Anthony Davis - Rutgers
6. Bruce Campbell - Maryland
7. Selvish Capers - WVU
8. Gabe Carimi - Winsconsin
9. Jarriel King - South Carolina
10. Jason Fox - Miami
WR:
1. Dez Bryant - Oklahoma State
2. Damian Williams - USC
3. Brandon LaFell - LSU
4. Golden Tate - Notre Dame
5. Mardy Gilyand - Cincinnati
6. Arrelious Benn - Illinois
7. Jeremy Williams - Tulane
8. Jacoby Ford - Clemson
9. Jordan Shipley - Texas
10. Terrance Tolliver - LSU
Safety:
1. Eric Berry - Tennessee
2. Taylor Mays - USC
3. Chad Jones - LSU
4. DeAndre McDaniel - Clemson
5. Nate Allen - USF
6. Morgan Burnett - Georgia Tech
7. Darrell Stuckey - Kansas
8. T.J. Ward - Oregon
9. Ahmad Black - Florida
10. Harry Coleman - LSU
CB:
1. Joe Haden - Florida
2. Ras - I - Dowling - Virginia
3. Kareem Jackson - Alabama
4. Donovan Warren - Michigan
5. Patrick Robinson - Florida State
6. Brandon Ghee - Wake Forest
7. Syd'Quan Thompson - California
8. Perrish Cox - Oklahoma State
9. Dominique Franks - Oklahoma
10. Trevard Linley - Kentucky
TE:
1. Jermain Gresham - Oklahoma
2. Weslye Saunders - South Carolina
3. Anthony McCoy - USC
4. Ed ****son - Oregon
5. Luke Stocker - Tennessee
6. Dennis Pitta - Brigham Young
7. Lance Kendricks - Winsconsin
8. Jeron Mastrud - Kansas State
9. Charlie Gantt - Michigan State
10. Mike McNeill - Nebraska
Center:
1. Maurkice Pouncey - Florida
2. Kristofer O'Dowd - USC
3. Stefen Wisniewski - Penn State
4. Matt Tennant - Boston College
5. John Moffitt - Winsconsin
6. Colin Baxter - Arizona
7. J.D. Walton - Baylor
8. Ryan McMahon - Florida State
9. Ted Larsen - North Carolina State
10. Eric Olsen - Notre Dame
QB:
1. Jimmy Clausen - Notre Dame
2. Sam Bradford - Oklahoma
3. Colt McCoy - Texas
4. Jake Locker - Washington
5. Tim Tebow - Florida
6. Jevan Snead - Mississippi
7. Tony Pike - Cincinnati
8. Dan LeFevour - Central Michigan
9. Jarrett Brown - WVU
10. John Skelton - Fordham